The first option looks great

First one looks perfect

These are too good but went with the first one since it showcases the product clearly

2nd one is fav. Eye catching

Anna, amazing work 🫠

Hi Anna! Personally, I prefer the second one. The strong tonal contrast between the hand and the light background instantly catches the eye, creating a great interplay between negative and positive space. Plus, the dynamic gesture and moving liquid make the scene feel unusual...

Go for number 1, it shows the full product and catches more attention.

1 for sure!

1 i’d say because it gets to catch more viewers attention

Number one is more direct and conversion focused

Nice work for me the second one

This feels really professional.

From a designer's perspective, "Option 2" is much more visually cohesive and eye-pleasing. The composition lacks abrupt contrast, creating a seamless, fluid look that avoids any visual jarring or color shock. While "Option 1" has a strong concept, the execution on the hand feels...

2 for me. Cleaner and more scroll stopping. ✨

dripping one, no contest

1 for me

🚀

love the visuals. how did you create them?

I prefer number 1

Awesome 👍

first one looks dope.

nice product

This looks good.

Love both of them, the first one is more catchy though

both look nice

Both 😁

First one for sure! Great job!

The water splash shot on the right has more movement and would stop a scroll faster than the flat lay. The 80% split makes sense for a carousel cover specifically, though the flat lay might work better as a slide further in once you already have their attention.

Love it 🧡 

great