The network for creativity
Join 1.25M professional creatives like you
Connect with clients, get discovered, and run your business 100% commission-free
Creatives on Contra have earned over $150M and we are just getting started
Back to feedPost
Taste Test
Which AI model would actually survive a real ad agency brief?
I put Kling 3.0 and Seedance 2.0 head-to-head with the exact same frames. Same prompt. Same creative direction.
And honestly, choosing between models is starting to feel a lot closer to choosing a director than choosing a tool.
Because each one interprets motion, realism, pacing, and atmosphere completely differently.
Prompt’s in the comments if you want to test it with your own product.
They both still need some extra editing and work, but I definitely have a favorite.
Who’s winning this one for you?
29 voted
39%
45 voted
61%
74 votes
Closed
The starting frame vs ending frame.
I generated both frames with Nano Banana 2 and used them as the transition points for the video generation.
I wanted it to feel like one continuous world: floating tension → gravity switches on → full liquid impact
This really nice weldone
Thank you!
Prompt below if you wanna test this with your own product ↓
A hyper-premium cinematic commercial for Poppi Raspberry Rose soda. The video begins in a surreal soft pink studio environment where a cold Raspberry Rose Poppi can floats weightlessly in mid-air surrounded by suspended...
It is impressive. How do you come up with such a detailed, precise prompt?
I use AI to write my prompts! I write my ideas in simple plain English with references, then ask it to help me write a more specific prompt. I usually specify which model I’m using so it understands how to improve the prompt for that tool!
They are both amazing. Hard to decide. You did great. Can I please get the prompt
of course!
A hyper-premium cinematic commercial for Poppi Raspberry Rose soda. The video begins in a surreal soft pink studio environment where a cold Raspberry Rose Poppi can floats weightlessly in mid-air surrounded by suspended raspberries, sparkling droplets, and...
Thank you
Seedance feels more realistic 👍
I agree!
Love this!
🥤 ♥️
I like the lighting more in the Seedance version, but I prefer the actual video from Kling
cool work =)
Yes, the lighting in Seedance makes it feel more realistic!
I think the flow and animation with Seedance is more engaging and effective than Kling
Yes! I think the flow and animation feel way more engaging too. I just don’t love that motion blur effect when the can drops 😅
nah that Kling is insaneeee! idc if it's least voted for hahaha that won in this house 🔥
Hahaha honestly, Kling is insane 😭 I just feel like the quality of the water isn’t quite there yet. But to be fair, both models seem to struggle with water physics/details right now.
Both look great, but i like the colors in Kling. Great work Sabrina 👍
🙌
Both of them are really great. 😍
🫶
I know it’s not technically the assignment, but the constant back-and-forth can rotation immediately reads as AI. What you probably want is something closer to a real-world high-speed product shot: all the ingredients thrown or dropped through the air, frozen in a bullet-time...
Also consider:
If you absolutely have to scrub the can back and forth, then the entire scene should move in sync with that control. Think record-scratch logic — the splash, particles, lighting, droplets, camera movement, everything locked to the same timeline interaction. Right...
This is such good feedback honestly 👏 Totally agree about the physics needing to feel more connected to sell the shot.
And impossible to relay that to AI. LOL.
I’ve pulled my hair out with camera directions. I typically have ChatGPT write my prompts for me.
Yeah, I totally agree! the water interaction is definitely where both models start to break a bit. I haven’t tried SuperGrok Imagine yet though, now I’m curious 👀
Curiosity is usually the best reason to test it 😉
SuperGrok Imagine is worth trying, especially for edge cases like water, motion, reflections, and prompt consistency.
If you test it against Kling or Seedance, I would genuinely be interested to hear what you notice. Happy to share a few prompt-engineering notes in DM if useful.
Yes exactly! It really does feel like choosing between different directors at this point 😭
And this is actually already part of my work! I run a branding studio, so I’ve been really interested in how these tools could fit into creative workflows and commercial production.
Kling is also good but Seedance looks more fine and gorg
Hahaha yes 😭 Kling is super impressive too but Seedance definitely feels a bit more refined and polished visually!
well its tough
I knooooow!! 😭
Great job
🙌
The first one has very weird physics.
Both fail at the rotation of the can as they jiggle back and forward, thats a dead giveaway in both.
Seedance does a very good "drop in water" effect, but that transition with the "star wars hyperspace" vibe is reeeeeally bad
I agree about the hyperspace effect 😭 I really dislike that part too. That would probably be the first thing I’d change!
But yeah, I totally agree about the can rotation. That little back-and-forth jitter immediately gives it away in both models!
Happy Monday💕 great minds.
Happy Monday!! 🙌
Great comparison! Seedance really does have that edge for commercial work. The way it handles product shots is impressive. Thanks for testing both side by side!
Totally agree!
Nice work!
Thank you!
Cool
🙌
Nice
Consider modifying the transition
Love it!
The network for creativity
Join 1.25M professional creatives like you
Connect with clients, get discovered, and run your business 100% commission-free
Creatives on Contra have earned over $150M and we are just getting started
Challenges
View all
Related posts
The atmospheric orange-on-black treatment gives the hero real momentum, and the branching flow diagram makes the product story feel tangible. The compact controls are a nice touch for guiding attention without clutter.
A continuation of the visual direction for an upcoming SaaS motion campaign 🚀
As an Art Director and Motion Designer on this project, my main focus isn't just creating appealing 3D assets, but making sure the visual system clearly reflects the product's core value.
In these stills, I'm visualizing automated AI workflows and interactive prompts using a light, tactile aesthetic to lower cognitive load. Good motion design should simplify the product narrative and ultimately turn viewers into signups.
Animated video launching soon! 🎬
A client gave this idea the green light before I even started building it.
Been using AI a lot lately to prototype ideas early, show the direction, and make sure we’re aligned before jumping into the actual build.
Such a good time saver.