Hi there! I'm working on a medical website and looking for a balance between usability and access...Hi there! I'm working on a medical website and looking for a balance between usability and access...
The network for creativity
Join 1.25M professional creatives like you
Connect with clients, get discovered, and run your business 100% commission-free
Creatives on Contra have earned over $150M and we are just getting started
Hi there! I'm working on a medical website and looking for a balance between usability and accessibility, along with modern UI solutions. What do you think – is Option 1 too complex for an audience aged 40+?
I checked it using Claude’s accessibility skill, and it says: “In terms of text and button readability, both options are absolutely on par – the numbers are nearly identical because they use the same typography on different backgrounds. Both are safe for an audience aged 40+" What do you think?

7 voted

54%

Version 1

6 voted

46%

Version 2

13 votes

Closed

Kabir's avatar
Split Creatives logo
I’d say Option 1 isn’t too complex if the hierarchy is clear. For a 40+ audience, readability and easy navigation matter more than keeping the UI super minimal.
Syed's avatar
I like the version 1 more but for Medical website, version 2 would be better
Nina's avatar
Thanks for your opinion! 🙌
Eric's avatar
Version 2 is easier to scan because the service cards and buttons stand apart. I would still test whether people can find the right service and book at 200% zoom before calling either option accessible.
Yusuf's avatar
Version 1 definitely feels sleeker, but Version 2 gives the content more breathing room and makes the information easier to scan.
Nazar's avatar
Yasno Design Agency logo
version 2, medical needs the calmer one
Maty's avatar
Interesting that you ran it through Claude's accessibility skill first, most people just eyeball it. If the typography checks out equal on both, I'd lean toward whichever version feels calmer for someone reading it while already anxious about a diagnosis. Have you tested either...
Amina's avatar
For healthcare, confidence and clarity should probably guide the final decision. Version 2🔥
Benjamin's avatar
TRUEFRAME logo
version 2 for me nina, the red words are easy to spot
Back to feed
The network for creativity
Join 1.25M professional creatives like you
Connect with clients, get discovered, and run your business 100% commission-free
Creatives on Contra have earned over $150M and we are just getting started