These 2020 banners for Sports Timing Systems took me hours upon hours. I had to use various tools...These 2020 banners for Sports Timing Systems took me hours upon hours. I had to use various tools...
The network for creativity
Join 1.25M professional creatives like you
Connect with clients, get discovered, and run your business 100% commission-free
Creatives on Contra have earned over $150M and we are just getting started
These 2020 banners for Sports Timing Systems took me hours upon hours. I had to use various tools and resources: 3D Max, 3D models, stock images, all mixed and edited in Photoshop. When I did the brand evolution in 2024, I swapped the 3D models for AI-gen, yet the final looks/effects were post-produced in Adobe PS. Which one feels neater, better, cooler, eye-catching? In both cases visuals were made as series, matching the full branding I developed at the time.

8 voted

26%

2020 / Redesign

23 voted

74%

2024 / Evolution

31 votes

Closed

Mariya's avatar
2019/2020 vs 2024
Post image
Post image
Diego's avatar
Honestly the 2024 one reads more like motion to me, but the 2020 version has that gritty real-race energy I kind of miss. Did the client push for the switch to AI-gen or was that your call?
Mariya's avatar
Agreed. AI really changed literally every field of our lives. My call, back then it wasn't as popular as of now, and it really cut some time and costs for my client, yet I did the final visuals manually, so it is like the old-way with superimposing different visuals, just swapping the stock for AI.
Diego's avatar
That makes sense, and doing the compositing by hand is probably why the 2024 set still feels like yours and not a prompt. If the next evolution landed on your desk today, would you let AI take more of the pipeline or pull it back?
Rahman's avatar
Outstanding work
Mariya's avatar
Thanks Rahman, which brand vision you prefer the most?
Celia's avatar
The 2024 one is SICK!
Mariya's avatar
Thanks, Celia! I still appreciate the old one, as it has pre-AI feeling. These days, I am starting to appreciate this even more.
Folorunsho's avatar
2020 Resign is nice for me
Mariya's avatar
Thank you, Folorunsho, it is great to hear your preferences. Do you like the visuals themself or the fact they are AI-free?
Boluwatife's avatar
Awesome going with the 2024 option
Mariya's avatar
Thank you so much, Boluwatife. You prefer the color system or just the visual direction?
Salome's avatar
Definitely A looks current and the design feels neater and cleaner
Mariya's avatar
Thanks, Salome! I am always doing my best for my brand identity systems to have 3-5 years of live without the need of redesign. Two years later, identity is still holding strong and we keep building pages and content. But no one know what the future will bring. :)
Maty's avatar
Swapping the 3D models for AI-gen in the 2024 version is such a clear snapshot of how fast production pipelines shifted in just four years. Did the AI-gen route actually save you time, or did most of the work just move into compositing and getting the lighting to match?
Mariya's avatar
Thanks for the great questions, Maty! Yes, the partial AI work saved time and costs, and I was able to keep adequate rate for the brand evolution, even after so many years and massive EU inflation... In 2024 AI was replacing stock images, but the designer behind was still the...
Nazar's avatar
Yasno Design Agency logo
2020 one for me, the 3d has more weight
Mariya's avatar
Thanks, Nazar, it is great to hear your opinion too.
Aminu's avatar
2024 still has it..
Back to feed
The network for creativity
Join 1.25M professional creatives like you
Connect with clients, get discovered, and run your business 100% commission-free
Creatives on Contra have earned over $150M and we are just getting started