v1: my own experience only. Interviewing two more owners next.
I ran STiX on Toast for two years, from picking a POS in Spring 2022 to closing in March 2024. This map follows that whole stretch from my side as the owner: setting it up, running game nights, getting paid, borrowing money, and closing down.
How I made it: from memory. I don't have the old statements or the contract anymore, and when the Toast account closed I lost access to it. I checked facts about Toast features and Colorado's surcharge law against Toast's support docs and the state statute. Every box on the map says where it came from.

What it says so far (one owner's account, so these are things to test, not findings yet):
The product won the sale, but the money side caused the pain. Toast's screens and search beat Aloha for my staff. Fees, deductions and cash timing are what hurt me as the owner.
The costs showed up after signing. Payroll fees were the first surprise. Card fees, monthly fees and loan repayments all came out of one deposit, so I saw what landed in the bank, not why.
Busy nights are where it breaks. Game nights meant 100+ tabs closing at once. One internet outage on St. Patrick's Day cost us about $5,000. We set the system up ourselves, and offline setup never came up.

Easy money, no way out. The loan took days to get. When we closed, there was no wind-down path: balances were still owed and my records went dark.
The top pain points:
St. Patrick's Day 2023. Comcast took the internet down. Our devices couldn't see each other's tabs and some tickets got lost. About $5,000 gone on the busiest day of the year.
Deductions from deposits. Fees, monthly charges and loan repayments came out of the money we needed for payroll and bills. It left us short exactly when we needed cash most.
Game nights. 100+ tabs all needing to close at once when the game ended.
What I'd fix first: a payout breakdown before every deposit. Show sales, card fees, monthly fees, loan holdback and anything else, then the amount that actually hits the bank, with a warning before any deduction that isn't routine. I never knew why a deposit was short until it already was.
What's next:
Ask Toast for my old statements and the Toast Capital loan records.
Interview two more owners: my in-laws, who run a restaurant in rural Colorado, and one more, ideally on a different POS.
Compare all three and update this map, marking what holds across owners and what was just STiX.
0 likes · 1 view · Nov 20, 2026
Mapped four years of running a sports bar on one POS, from setup to closing, to find where the money side hurt owners.