BLOG: Why Locals Love Nantucket in the Off-Season

Nantucket, often revered as a summer paradise, embraces a quieter rhythm in the off-season. Beyond the idyllic summer getaway, Nantucket is popular for its magical holiday season with the Nantucket Christmas Stroll drawing in visitors from across New England. But what is the island like once the spectacle is over? For island locals, it falls back into a quieter, serene rhythm. With a rich history, friendly local businesses, an impressive culinary scene, and stunning natural beauty — Nantucket is an ideal home for year-round residents.

It’s a Culinary Paradise

Nantucket’s culinary scene extends beyond its famous five-star dining. The island is spoiled with locally owned gems, from cozy coffee shops to casual dining spots and fresh seafood joints that remain open year-round.

But First, Island Coffee

Part of many Nantucket locals’ routines is Island Coffee. If you stop into the shop any day of the week, you will find it bustling with locals picking up their daily brew before heading to the nearby ferry terminal. The shop is also a cozy spot to read a book while enjoying one of their delicious pastries.

Weeknights at Foggy Nantucket

During the cold and gray winter months, Foggy Nantucket is flooded with the local crowd indulging in their classic comfort food. The diverse menu caters to every palate, including mouth-watering pizzas and savory BBQ dishes.

Pick Up Today’s Catch at Sayle’s Seafood

Seafood is synonymous with life on Nantucket. And for locals, Sayle’s Seafood ranks at the top of the list for fresh, ready-to-eat seafood. A great spot for take-out, you can grab your favorite dish to enjoy on their waterfront deck or take it to enjoy at home. Sayle’s Seafood is a one-stop-shop fish market for all things seafood including local scallops, live lobsters, and homemade clam chowder.

While Nantucket’s culinary scene thrives year-round, its small businesses offer cozy retreats from the winter chill. Check out these local treasures beloved by residents.

Get Lost in Mitchell’s Book Corner

Escape the winter weather with a visit to Mitchell’s Book Corner, a local bookstore offering an expansive selection for readers of all kinds. Open since 1968, Mitchell’s Book Corner is a community staple. You can spend hours getting lost in their bookshelves! The perfect location to grab a new read before cozying up at home by the fireplace.

Design and Style at Nantucket Looms

The embodiment of the Nantucket lifestyle, Nantucket Looms is a multi-faceted business that celebrates local artisans and connects the community through handwoven textiles, furnishing, and expert design services. For over 50 years, Nantucket Looms has produced products that capture the island’s rich history, culture, and distinct aesthetic.

Dress like the Locals at Murray’s Toggery Shop

Famous for its iconic Nantucket Reds collection, Murray’s Toggery Shop is the home of classic Nantucket apparel. Open for over 75 years, this family-owned establishment has stood the test of time, passing through multiple generations. Murray’s is one of the island’s longest-running businesses, offering classic Nantucket apparel alongside contemporary pieces.

Beyond the seasons of high energy, Nantucket maintains its charm for year-round residents. If you’re interested in calling Nantucket home, let’s connect! Allow me to be your resource for all things Nantucket real estate. Let’s work together to find you your dream home in Nantucket.