Consumer Behavior Research & Publication

Miguel Luzuriaga, PhD

Suggested Citation
Miguel Luzuriaga, Antonio Heras and Oliver Kunze (2020), "Hurting Others versus Hurting Myself, a Dilemma for Our Autonomous Vehicle", Review of Behavioral Economics: Vol. 7: No. 1, pp 1-30. http://dx.doi.org/10.1561/105.00000115
© 2020 M. Luzuriaga, A. Heras and O. Kunze
Subjects
Keywords
JEL Codes: C91, D81, D91, R41
Experiments, Ethical dilemmas, Trolley problem, Risk-aversione, Social preferences

Abstract

Autonomous Vehicles (AVs) will soon be a reality on our roads. Up to now, their standard behaviour is predetermined since it is the result of programmed algorithms. Under risky traffic situations, however, they will face dilemmas such as, deciding between affecting the passenger or affecting others. Thus, in this experiment, we investigate how people solve a reframed version of the well-known Trolley-problem [Foot, P. 1967. “The problem of abortion and the doctrine of double effect,” Oxford Review 5: 5–15] under two conditions: when subjects actually drive a vehicle simulator, versus when they solve the same dilemma by programming a hypothetical AV. In both settings, the participants’ decisions have real monetary consequences, which affect others and themselves. Our Probit models indicate that subjects who program an AV and who are more cautious in terms of speed are less (more) likely to sacrifice a pedestrian (themselves) compared to those who actually drive and prefer a higher driving speed. Moreover, we find that the subjects’ choices are associated with risk aversion but not with moral beliefs or loss aversion. Implications of the driving vs programming discrepancies for the design of AVs algorithms are discussed.
DOI:10.1561/105.00000115
Like this project
0

Posted Jan 1, 2025

We study driving behavior, risk-loss aversion, moral beliefs and implications of the programming for the design of Autonomous Vehicles are discussed.

Editorial Excellence in Scientific Publishing
Editorial Excellence in Scientific Publishing
Experts' Assesment of UX
Experts' Assesment of UX
UX & HMI Research and Scientific Publication
UX & HMI Research and Scientific Publication