Servant Leadership or Silent Submission: A Longform Article
Natasha Mulenga
Servant Leadership or Silent Submission? Reclaiming a Misunderstood Biblical Principle
Christian Culture & Leadership Publication | Faith & Modern Society
THE CHALLENGE
A forward-thinking Christian publication sought a nuanced, historically-grounded essay that could navigate the sensitive and often polarizing debate around submission and leadership within the church. They needed a piece that moved beyond simplistic arguments, offering both a profound critique of "power-over" structures and a constructive, biblically-rooted vision for healthy, mutual relationships.
MY APPROACH
I crafted a compelling narrative that wove a poignant modern tragedy with a powerful historical analogy—the pre-Reformation control of Scripture. This framework exposed a repeated pattern of spiritual authority being twisted into a tool for control. The essay then introduced the clarifying lens of "power-over" versus "power-to/with," integrating research from historians like Beth Allison Barr to distinguish man-made hierarchy from true, Christ-like servant leadership.
THE RESULT
The piece delivered a rigorous yet accessible analysis that resonated deeply with readers. It provided a vocabulary to critique harmful dynamics while painting a hopeful, practical picture of mutual flourishing grounded in scripture. It stands as a model for writing that is both intellectually substantive and emotionally compelling on complex matters of faith and culture.
Article Preview:
God’s design has always been that we are whole in Him, how can one be whole when they are constantly broken and crippled under spiritual authority aimed to control. He came to set us free, not constrict us. The goal of submission and biblical leadership is the unhindered pursuit of God’s purpose by all people for all people. He has shown time and time again how important both men and women are in His plans and demonstrated that it does not matter who it is, He can make greatness come out of anyone. If only the worship leader had been in a framework of biblical love and service, protected, her calling celebrated and her husband held accountable. his sacrificial leadership would have been met with her submission — creating safety, not silencing her. That is the freedom and mutual flourishing that reflects God’s kingdom.
READ THE FULL PIECE
Read Article Here
If you would like to work together, reach out right here on Contra or find me through my email: mnatashabwalya@gmail.com. If you would like to read more from me, find me on Substack or Medium or connect with me on LinkedIn.
Like this project
Posted Dec 9, 2025
A historical essay using the Reformation as a lens to critique "power-over" leadership and reclaim biblical, mutual servant leadership.
