Before jumping into the redesign, I put on my detective hat and did some serious research on other closed-community apps and niche forums. I wasn’t just looking at what they did well—I wanted to see where they struggled so Tribe could fill the gaps. So, I dove deep into Discord, Reddit, Geneva, and WhatsApp to understand their strengths and weaknesses.
Discord – Originally built for gamers, Discord is a real-time chat app where communities (servers) have different channels for discussions, voice chats, and bots. It’s highly interactive and keeps users engaged.
✅ High engagement, feels alive
❌ Overwhelming UI, too chaotic
Reddit – A massive forum platform where communities (subreddits) are organized by topics. Users upvote or downvote posts, keeping the best discussions visible.
✅ Great discussion quality, strong moderation
❌ Not private, some toxic communities
Geneva – A newer platform designed specifically for private communities. It offers structured discussions in a clean, modern interface, positioned as a more organized alternative to Discord.
✅ Clean design, built for communities
❌ Low user activity, feels empty
WhatsApp – A messaging app that people often repurpose for group discussions, even though it wasn’t designed for that.
✅ Familiar, easy to use
❌ No structure, messages get lost