Fresh & Bold gets my vote. That deep red makes the can impossible to miss, and the design lets the product do the talking instead of the lifestyle shot around it. Sweet & Playful is lovely photography, but on a shelf I think the red one is the one you'd actually pick up first.
The first is a black woven speaker with a brass dial, set on a cream block against acid green, flat daylight, the wordmark printed small on the grille, a heavy black sans headline across the top.
The second is the same speaker shot close and low on teal velvet, the weave filling the frame, a brass plate on the grille and the dial catching the only warm light, the headline in cream serif.