ChatGPT vs. Gemini: Which Created the Better Perfume Ad?

ChatGPT vs. Gemini: Which Created the Better Perfume Ad?ChatGPT vs. Gemini: Which Created the Better Perfume Ad?

The network for creativity

Join 1.25M professional creatives like you

Connect with clients, get discovered, and run your business 100% commission-free

Creatives on Contra have earned over $150M and we are just getting started

Back to feedPost

Taste Test

Create your own

Olubade Esther

pro

• 9h

Same prompt. Same concept. Two AI tools. 👀

I gave ChatGPT and Gemini the exact same prompt to create a luxury perfume ad creative.

No changes. No extra instructions.

Now I want to know what YOU think:

Which creative did it better?

🔵 A— Gemini

🟣 B— ChatGPT

Look at the overall concept, visual quality, composition, typography, and how “ad-ready” it feels.

Who wins this round? 👀

Vote below and tell me what made you choose your answer.

#AIContent #AIAdvertising #AdCreative #CreativeStrategy #ChatGPT #Gemini #SocialMediaManager #SocialMediaStrategy #SocialMediaMarketing #MarketingStrategy #DigitalMarketing #ContentCreation

AI Content Creation gemini Google Gemini Social Media Management Social Media Strategy ChatGPT

9 votes

Ends in 1d

Tomiwa Folorunso

pro

• 9h

B for me. You can easily tell what the product is because of how the "camera" is focused on it and then the title and the descriptive texts at the right side is excellent. ChatGPT executed the task better than Gemini in this case.👍

Mostafa Moamen

• 5h

Honestly B is more focused on the product 🎉🎉

Noah Tukur

• 3h

Wow

Dmitri Bainov

• Sep 28

Continuing my series of short motion videos for a crypto project.

Which coin looks better? (Rendered on a transparent background, by the way.)

If your product needs something similar, feel free to reach out :)

3D Design Motion Design

67 voted

74%

24 voted

26%

91 votes

Closed

Aminu Ganiyat

• Sep 29

B took the lead for me

Zulker Naeen Hamim

pro

• Sep 28

Two short motion ads for Instaheadshots, an app that turns ordinary selfies into studio-quality professional headshots with AI.

🎬 Ad 1: "Slide to Unlock" (10s) A product-flow spot. It opens on a glowing slide-to-unlock button, then shows the app's processing and generating screens as a casual selfie becomes a polished headshot. It ends on the brand and a "Try Instaheadshots" CTA.

🎬 Ad 2: "Everyone's Upgrading" (20s) A social-proof spot. Notification cards stack up as Sarah, Daniel and Priya each post a new profile photo within one week. The punchline is "everyone is using the exact same Instaheadshots to upgrade," which works on FOMO and ends on a clear CTA.

What I did: concept, motion design, UI animation, kinetic typography, sound sync

7 voted

39%