Which can would you have picked?

Guud Energy is an organic, zero-sugar energy drink from San Diego. Good product, but the can wasn’t helping it: white type on bright gradients, too many messages competing, and the hero ingredient buried in a list.

We presented three directions, each across the full flavor range: But I'm sharing two here, as the system allows me to share only two The client picked one. Which would you have gone with, and why? I’ll share their choice in the comments.