When BMW announced the redesign of the 4 Series Convertible, long-time fans were not pleased with the decision to ditch the hard top. As if the massive grills weren’t controversial enough, right?

Let’s just say that some people were disappointed by the German automaker’s new car design. But BMW has created a luxury brand that consumers can’t seem to get enough of. Despite the polarizing looks, the new 4 Series Convertible can be a fantastic car for the right owner.

If you are in the market for a cabriolet, you may wonder: Should I go with the F-chassis or G-chassis droptop? Let’s explore some key features of each generation and see how they stack up against each other.

The BMW 4 Series Convertible was first introduced in 2013. Since then, it has gone through a pretty major makeover. The F-chassis (F33) dominated the market before giving way to its successor—the G-chassis (G23)—in 2021.

Upon first glance, the G23 differentiates itself with a rag top and aggressive grills. Many early enthusiasts prefer the modest front-end and the transformer-like folding hard top. And for good reason! There is something special about a convertible that looks like a coupe when the roof is up.

Though some dislike the redesigned 4 Series cabriolet, it shouldn’t be dismissed entirely. BMW retained the classic sports car feel while adding modern touches and advanced technology. The automaker also preserved some of the predecessor’s best features: functionality, performance, and a simple cockpit design.

The BMW 4 Series Convertible strikes the perfect balance between form and function. It is roomy enough for four passengers to travel in comfort—a rare combination. It’s not every day that you come across a sleek 2-door sports car that can also be a family hauler!

The F33 offers hard-top aficionados the best of both worlds: an open-air ride or a sporty coupe drive depending on their mood. Not only does it look more elegant than its successor, but it also discourages vandalism by would-be thieves.

Even though some might think that the canvas roof looks cheap, the G23 does offer some advantages over its predecessor. For example, owners enjoy more trunk real estate with the top down. The new model is 40% lighter than the retractable hard top, making it more aerodynamic and gas efficient.

If you’re looking for a car that handles the road with ease, look no further than the BMW 4 Series Convertible. It has a powerful engine, fast acceleration, and impressive handling. The base model 430i has a 2.0L four-cylinder engine that outputs 255 horsepower and 295 lb-ft of torque. Crave more power? Go with the M440i for extra vroom: its 3.0L six-cylinder engine puts out 382 horsepower and 396 lb-ft of torque!

Unlike sports cars in the same class, the 4 Series droptop boasts excellent fuel economy. On average, you can expect a combined MPG of 27 between city and highway, or 25 city and 34 highway. Not too shabby for a motor that packs a punch!

BMW vehicles are known for their easy-to-navigate, yet attractive cockpit design. Both generations of the 4 Series Convertible have a simple cabin that is pleasing to the eye. The iDrive displays clear GPS directions, while the ergonomic console puts controls within reach. Depending on the spec you get, you may be able to integrate Apple CarPlay or Android Auto. Stream music and receive texts without taking your hands off the wheel!

The F-chassis may win for exterior appearance. But the G-chassis takes first place when it comes to interior design. BMW added an improved infotainment system, more cabin storage, and innovative features like touchless gesture controls.

There are few things in life as pleasurable as driving a convertible, and the BMW 4 Series is one of them.

The F-chassis is a favorite among auto enthusiasts and continues to perform well in today’s car market. Will BMW ever bring back the hard top? Only time will tell. If having a metal roof is non-negotiable for you, consider shopping for a newer F33 (2017-2020). If you can get past the canvas top and front fascia, the G23 (2021+) is a thrilling motor with superior features and technology.

Regardless of which you choose, there is no doubt that this car is one of the best convertibles on the road today. You may just fall head over wheels on the first drive!