Startups: When Is the Right Time to Hire an SEO Expert?

Gordon Ibarra

SEO Specialist

Digital Marketer

Content Strategist

Growth Marketer

Google Analytics

SEMrush

Ahrefs

Moz

Venture Capital & Entrepreneurship

Startups: When Is the Right Time to Hire an SEO Expert?

I used to think SEO was something I’d “get to later.” You know, after I launched the product, found product-market fit, and had time to breathe. But “later” usually meant “when traffic flatlined, and I had no idea why.”

When I started freelancing with early-stage startups, I noticed the same thing kept happening. SEO wasn’t ignored—it just wasn’t prioritized. Founders were juggling funding decks, product bugs, and a dozen Slack channels. Search visibility? Low on the list.

But then came the questions: Why aren’t we ranking? Why is traffic dropping? What’s our content doing? Often, those were signals that SEO had been left out of the build.

So, when is the right time to think about SEO? Let’s not overcomplicate it—just start by understanding the role it plays in startup growth.

The Role of SEO in Startup Growth

Search visibility is what makes a small, unknown brand discoverable. Without it, even the best product ends up buried under page two of Google 🪦.

Organic traffic builds slowly, but when it starts working, it doesn’t stop every time your paid ads budget runs out. That steady stream signals to both users and investors that people are actually looking for what you offer.

Delaying SEO often means building a site that later needs to be torn apart and rebuilt—technical fixes, broken links, missed opportunities. It's like skipping insulation during a house build and then wondering why it’s freezing inside.

“SEO is like compound interest. The sooner you invest, the more it quietly builds behind the scenes.”

Founders who wait for traction before considering SEO often end up hiring in panic mode—after rankings drop or competitors pull ahead. By then, it’s not a strategy. It’s damage control.

Top Indicators You Need Outside Help

Stagnant web traffic and dwindling lead generation.

Overworked marketing teams lacking specialized SEO skills.

Recent or upcoming product launches requiring visibility.

Startups often try to manage SEO internally until something breaks—or simply stops moving. These are the moments when outside help becomes less optional and more operational, making it the ideal time to hire an SEO expert.

1. Traffic Is Stagnant

When organic rankings flatline or decline, it usually signals deeper issues. Pages that once ranked may be outdated, over-optimized, or technically blocked from being crawled.

If you're publishing content regularly but conversion rates stay low, that disconnect often points to targeting the wrong keywords or poor search intent alignment. More traffic doesn’t always mean better traffic.

“Publishing more blogs won’t fix content that no one’s searching for.”

Stagnant traffic is rarely solved by writing more—it’s solved by identifying why the current content isn’t performing.

2. Team Is Swamped

Keyword research, page audits, and technical cleanup take focused time. If your marketing team is already stretched thin, SEO becomes a background task—done quickly, or not at all.

Small teams often prioritize product launches, email campaigns, or user onboarding over page speed, schema markup, or fixing broken links. These SEO tasks are important, but easy to postpone when resources are limited.

When SEO work competes with everything else, it rarely wins.

3. New Product Launches

Launching new features or products without SEO support limits discoverability. Even with a solid PR push or paid ads, search visibility plays a long-term role in adoption.

If no one is searching for your product yet, SEO helps create those pathways—targeting terms adjacent to the problem you solve. If people are already searching, you’ll want to be there before your competitors are.

“A product launch without SEO is like throwing a party and not giving anyone the address.”

Early visibility during a launch helps build compounding traffic over time. No indexed landing page = no search impressions = no clicks. 🕳️

In-House vs. Freelance Routes

Hiring in-house means building a dedicated SEO role inside your team. Freelance means bringing in someone for a defined period or project. The difference usually comes down to cost, control, and capacity.

In-house hires often come with higher long-term costs—salary, benefits, onboarding, and management. Freelancers tend to operate on flexible terms and are scoped to specific outcomes. For startups with uncertain timelines or shifting priorities, this distinction matters.

"Hiring in-house can feel like buying a car when you're not sure where you're going yet."

Platforms like Contra simplify sourcing by offering commission-free access to independent SEO professionals. This reduces overhead and removes the need for retainer-heavy agency structures.

1. Upfront Investment

Full-time SEO hires typically cost between $60K–$100K+ annually, depending on experience and location. This doesn’t include tools, training, or additional team support.

Freelance SEO experts are project-based or hourly, making it easier to control budgets. Startups can allocate funds to specific outcomes—like auditing a site, optimizing a launch page, or improving Core Web Vitals—rather than covering a fixed monthly salary.

The difference is predictability vs. flexibility. Full-time hires offer continuity; freelancers offer adaptability.

2. Project Scope

Long-term site architecture work, ongoing content strategies, or global SEO rollouts may require consistent attention. An in-house hire is better suited for this type of sustained effort.

For limited campaigns—like launching a new product or fixing a technical issue—a freelance SEO expert can handle the work without ongoing commitment. This works especially well when the project scope is clear and timelines are short.

"If you're still deciding what to do next quarter, bringing on a freelancer might be faster—and less permanent—than opening a headcount."

Scope also affects collaboration. In-house hires may align more closely with brand voice and internal workflows. Freelancers typically focus on delivery and measurable SEO outcomes.

Steps to Select the Right SEO Expert

Before hiring anyone, it’s helpful to understand what you're trying to solve. If traffic is declining, the priority might be technical fixes. If you're preparing for a launch, the focus may shift to content optimization or keyword strategy. The more specific the goal, the easier it becomes to assess whether someone is qualified to help.

Looking at portfolios or proposals can quickly filter out candidates who don’t operate in your niche. An SEO expert who specializes in multi-location local SEO won't bring the same value to a B2B SaaS platform. Niche relevance matters—especially if your space has unique search behavior or compliance requirements.

"If their first suggestion is ‘more blog posts,’ ask what they’d write about and why."

Initial calls or audits can reveal a lot. Ask how they'd approach your situation, not just what they’ve done in the past. The best-fit candidate already has a mental checklist by the time they’ve read your homepage.

1. Prioritize Key Skills

Technical SEO includes crawling, indexing, site structure, schema markup, and Core Web Vitals. It often gets overlooked because it’s not visible in content—but it directly affects whether your pages can rank at all.

Content optimization includes keyword targeting, internal linking, and metadata. It’s what helps your pages show up for the right terms and convert once a user lands.

Some industries require additional context. A healthtech startup may need someone familiar with HIPAA-compliant content publishing. A fintech company will want someone who understands YMYL (Your Money Your Life) guidelines.

Industry-specific experience reduces time spent explaining basic terminology and increases the likelihood of relevant, high-impact recommendations.

2. Evaluate Strategies

Ask for a sample audit, or a breakdown of how they’d approach your homepage or a key product page. You’re not looking for free consulting—you’re looking for how they think.

If the recommendations are generic (e.g., “write more content,” “improve page speed”), it’s a red flag. Look for observations tied to your actual site, such as slow-loading JavaScript or misaligned search intent on a landing page.

"SEO isn't just about keywords—it's about knowing which keywords belong on which pages, and why."

Brand voice matters when SEO recommendations involve content. If their sample title tags or meta descriptions sound generic or forced, it may create more editing work later.

3. Set Clear Expectations

Ask how they define success. If they say “better rankings,” ask which keywords. If they say “more traffic,” ask how much and by when. Vague answers make it difficult to measure whether the partnership is working.

Milestones can be tied to specific deliverables (e.g., technical audit complete by May 1), or to performance metrics (e.g., +20% organic traffic by July). Not every goal will be hit, but the process should be transparent.

Timelines depend on the size of the site and the nature of the work. Technical fixes might show results in weeks. Content strategies usually take a few months. Communication should reflect that.

If a freelancer promises page-one rankings in 30 days, proceed with caution 🕵️‍♂️

Goals, Budgets, and Return on Investment

Startups working with lean teams and limited capital often delay SEO investment due to cost uncertainty. Setting a clear goal for the ROI timeline—whether six months or one year—helps define how much to allocate based on current stage and growth targets.

SEO outcomes are usually gradual. Short-term results may include improved crawlability or ranking stability. Long-term impact tends to show up in increased organic traffic, lower customer acquisition costs, and more qualified inbound leads over time.

“If a strategy sounds like a shortcut, it’s probably a detour.”

Unrealistic promises—like guaranteed first-page rankings in 30 days—often lead to wasted budget. Most search engines update algorithms regularly, making quick wins unpredictable and hard to sustain. Projects focused on stability, relevance, and user experience tend to yield more durable results.

1. Outline Clear KPIs

Common SEO KPIs include organic sessions, percentage of traffic from non-branded keywords, conversion rates from search, and lead quality. These metrics are usually tracked monthly or quarterly, depending on traffic volume.

For startups nearing a product launch or funding round, tying KPIs to those specific milestones helps track outcomes more meaningfully. For example, targeting a 25% increase in organic demo signups before a Series A pitch can align SEO performance with investor expectations.

Avoid tracking too many metrics at once. Focus on 2–3 that directly relate to business outcomes, such as landing page conversions or keyword ranking improvements for high-intent queries.

2. Allocate Proper Funds

A reasonable SEO budget for early-stage startups falls between $1,500–$5,000/month depending on scope. This includes freelance hours, tools (like Ahrefs or Screaming Frog), and content production. Higher budgets are often needed for technical overhauls or link-building campaigns.

Prioritization depends on immediate needs. For example, if the site has no indexation issues but lacks traffic, the focus may shift to content strategy and keyword mapping. If traffic is strong but bounce rates are high, UX or technical audits may be more relevant.

“The SEO budget isn’t just what you spend—it’s how little of it leaks into things that aren’t SEO.”

Using commission-free platforms like Contra reduces overhead, allowing more of the budget to go toward actual SEO work instead of platform fees or agency markups.

FAQs About Hiring an SEO Expert

Is hiring an SEO expert worth it?

If organic traffic contributes to lead generation or revenue, hiring an SEO expert often leads to a measurable return. The return depends on the site’s current condition, competition in the niche, and how early SEO is integrated. For startups already producing content or preparing for a launch, the ROI tends to increase over time as visibility compounds.

“SEO doesn’t spike—it stacks.”

Investments made in technical fixes or content optimization in Q2 may not significantly impact performance until Q3 or Q4.

What is the typical cost for an SEO consultant?

As of April 2025, hourly rates for freelance SEO consultants range from $50 to $150 depending on experience, location, and project complexity. Monthly retainers typically fall between $1,500 and $5,000, with project-based fees fluctuating between $2,000 and $10,000.

“If it sounds too cheap, it’s probably just keyword stuffing in disguise.”

Costs vary more when deliverables are undefined. A technical audit may be priced as a flat project, while ongoing content strategy or link building is usually billed monthly. Freelancers often charge less than agencies due to lower overhead and simpler scopes.

Can a freelance SEO specialist handle my entire campaign?

A freelance SEO specialist can manage an entire campaign if the scope is clearly defined and the timeline is realistic. Tasks like keyword research, technical audits, content planning, on-page optimization, and basic reporting are typically within scope. Complex areas like international SEO, large-scale link building, or CMS migrations may require collaboration with developers or other specialists.

“One person can’t run a newsroom, but they can fix the front page.”

Freelancers often work asynchronously or in sprints, which suits startups working on specific goals—like launching a new product or improving site speed—rather than ongoing campaign management. Retainers can cover multiple SEO functions, but communication and documentation become more important as the workload grows.

How soon can I see results?

Initial results from an SEO engagement depend on the site’s current state, the type of work done, and how quickly changes are implemented. Technical improvements like fixing redirects, removing crawl errors, or improving page speed may show an impact within 4–6 weeks. Content-related changes often take longer—typically 2–4 months to show movement in rankings, and 4–6 months to influence traffic or conversions.

“SEO timelines are like shipping estimates—faster if you don’t miss the window, slower if something breaks.”

Search engine indexing delays, competition level, and algorithm updates can also affect timelines. For newer domains or industries with low search volume, results may appear slower due to fewer data signals. Campaigns focused on long-tail keywords or niche queries tend to show earlier wins.

Moving Forward With Confidence

Guesswork tends to show up when growth stalls and there’s no clear reason why. Traffic dips, conversions drop, but nothing obvious stands out in analytics. In those moments, having a documented SEO baseline—site structure, keyword targets, crawl health—makes diagnosis faster and less reactive.

Data-driven insight comes from regular audits. These include technical scans, ranking checks, and performance reviews tied to specific business goals. For example, a startup planning a Series A might track organic demo signups from high-intent pages. If signups slow down, the audit identifies whether that’s due to lost rankings, slower page speed, or competitor content shifts.

Hiring isn’t always the next step. Sometimes the structure is solid, and only small adjustments are needed—refreshing outdated blog posts, cleaning up broken links, or fixing metadata. Other times, the issues are larger, like cannibalized keywords or unindexed landing pages. The audit defines the scope, not the guess.

Freelance SEO experts offer the flexibility to address those findings without long-term commitment. Through platforms like Contra, startups can engage commission-free professionals for defined projects—such as a technical audit, a new site migration, or launch page optimization. This avoids locking into retainers or allocating budget to overhead costs.

"Hiring an SEO expert to fix a traffic drop is like calling a plumber after the basement floods. Regular checkups are cheaper."

SEO doesn’t stand still. Algorithm updates, new competitors, product changes, and team turnover all shift the baseline. A working SEO strategy in Q1 may underperform by Q3 without updates. Running audits every quarter or after major site changes keeps the roadmap aligned.

Startups often evolve faster than their websites do. New use cases appear, ICPs shift, and messaging pivots. Without periodic SEO reviews, those changes can dilute relevance rather than improve reach.

Working with freelancers on a project-by-project basis makes it easier to align SEO work with those shifts. It removes friction from the hiring process and enables startups to focus resources on what’s working—without platform fees eating into the budget.

Like this project

Posted Apr 14, 2025

Startups: When is the right time to hire an SEO expert? Learn key signs, timing, and strategies to grow traffic before rankings drop or leads stall.

Likes

Views