Setting Your Budget: What to Expect When You Hire SEO Experts
Gordon Ibarra
Setting Your Budget: What to Expect When You Hire SEO Experts
Table of Contents
Steps to Plan Your SEO Budget
1. Assess Current Online Visibility
2. Define the Scope of Work
3. Set Clear KPIs
4. Decide on an Ideal Timeline
5. Allocate Funds Wisely
Ways to Choose Your SEO Expert
1. Freelancer Pros and Cons
2. Agency Pros and Cons
3. In-House Pros and Cons
Factors That Affect Monthly Costs
1. Content Creation Needs
2. Technical Site Fixes
3. Level of Competition
Tips to Track ROI and Justify Spending
Frequently Asked Questions about Hiring SEO Experts
How much does it cost to hire an SEO expert?
Should I consider a performance-based contract?
What if I only have a small budget?
Do I need extra tools for SEO tasks?
Final Thoughts on Budget Setting
Setting Your Budget: What to Expect When You Hire SEO Experts
Last week, I was on a call with a client who asked, “Is $1,000 a month enough for SEO?” I’ve heard this question in some form at least twice a week for the past year. And honestly, I get it — SEO pricing is all over the place, especially if you’re hiring for the first time.
When I first started freelancing, I underestimated how much time SEO work actually demands. Not just writing or optimizing a few pages. I’m talking about audits, technical cleanup, content strategy, link building, and reporting — all of which require different skills, tools, and hours.
This article is based on how I approach budgeting conversations with clients. It’s not one-size-fits-all. But there are patterns, and there are numbers — and they can help set expectations before you commit to hire SEO experts.
Table of Contents
(Brief explanation: Provide a quick glance at each main section to help readers navigate the article.)
Steps to Plan Your SEO Budget
Covers how to calculate a starting point for your SEO budget based on business goals, timelines, and internal resources.
Ways to Choose Your SEO Expert
Breaks down different hiring options — freelancers, agencies, hybrids — and how each one affects your budget and workflow.
Factors That Affect Monthly Costs
Explains what variables increase or decrease SEO pricing, like site complexity, competition level, and the type of services needed.
Tips to Track ROI and Justify Spending
Walks through how to measure the impact of your SEO investment using real metrics, not just keyword rankings.
Frequently Asked Questions about Hiring SEO Experts
Answers common questions I get from clients during budget planning: hourly vs. monthly, contract length, and scope clarity.
Final Thoughts on Budget Setting
Summarizes the key takeaways and shares how I personally approach budget alignment with clients, especially when expectations shift mid-project.
Steps to Plan Your SEO Budget
Planning an SEO budget involves five core steps. Each one sets parameters that affect how much to invest, when, and where.
1. Assess Current Online Visibility
Start by checking how your website performs in search results today. Use free tools like Google Search Console, MozBar, or Ahrefs’ site audit to check indexed pages, technical errors, and keyword rankings.
A basic audit gives insight into your domain authority, backlink profile, crawl errors, and top-performing pages. This helps identify if you're starting from scratch or optimizing existing momentum.
“If your website hasn’t been updated since 2017, your SEO budget won’t be ‘light.’”
— Me, after reviewing a client site with Flash buttons
2. Define the Scope of Work
Clarify whether the SEO focus is local (e.g. one city), national, or international. Local SEO typically involves Google Business Profile optimization, local citations, and location-specific content. National and international scopes require broader keyword strategies, language localization, and more technical infrastructure.
This scope determines team size and deliverables. For example, targeting a single city may involve 15–20 keywords. Competing across multiple countries could mean 200+ keyword clusters and domain-level work.
3. Set Clear KPIs
KPIs (Key Performance Indicators) connect SEO work to outcomes. Common ones include:
Organic traffic growth
Keyword position changes for specific terms
Increase in form submissions, product sales, or demo bookings
Choose 2–3 KPIs that reflect business goals. Avoid vague targets like “get better rankings.” Instead, aim for specifics like “increase ranking of ‘eco-friendly packaging supplier’ from #12 to top 3.”
4. Decide on an Ideal Timeline
The faster you want results, the more resources you’ll need. A 3-month sprint might require aggressive link building, technical fixes, and paid tools — all at once. A 9–12 month timeline allows gradual rollout.
Timelines also affect cash flow. A $12,000 budget can be spent as $1,000/month over a year or $4,000/month over three months. Same total, different intensity.
5. Allocate Funds Wisely
Basic SEO packages focus on audits, metadata updates, and light content work. These often cost $500–$1,500/month. Mid-level packages include backlink outreach, technical SEO, and blog content, ranging from $2,000–$5,000/month.
Advanced SEO involves AI-driven content, predictive analytics, and custom dashboards. These often start at $8,000/month and go up based on the site’s complexity and goals.
“I once asked a client what their budget was. They said ‘whatever it takes.’ Six weeks later, they ghosted after the first invoice.”
— Freelance SEO consultant, probably every week
Pricing also depends on who you hire — freelancer, agency, or in-house — which is covered in the next section.
Ways to Choose Your SEO Expert
There are three main hiring paths when budgeting for SEO: freelancers, agencies, and in-house teams. Each comes with a different cost structure, level of control, and workload distribution. Choosing the right model depends on internal capacity, the scope of your SEO goals, and how quickly you expect results.
1. Freelancer Pros and Cons
Freelancers are often the most affordable option. Hourly rates typically fall between $50 and $150, with some experienced consultants charging $200+ for advanced technical work. Many offer project-based packages starting at $500, especially for audits or small site optimizations.
Platforms like Contra offer commission-free hiring, which helps retain more of the freelancer’s rate for actual work rather than platform fees. This improves budget clarity and can reduce overhead by 15–20% compared to fee-based platforms.
“Freelancers are like espresso shots: great for focus, not for full-course meals.”
Freelancers work independently and usually manage 3–5 clients at a time. This limits turnaround speed for large or urgent projects. They may also specialize in one area of SEO (content, technical, or local), so hiring more than one person is sometimes necessary for full coverage.
2. Agency Pros and Cons
Agencies offer bundled services with access to content creators, link builders, technical specialists, and account managers. Monthly retainers typically range from $2,500 to $7,500, with enterprise plans exceeding $10,000 depending on scope and integration needs.
Costs are higher due to overhead, team structure, and proprietary tools. However, agencies often include CRM integration, marketing automation, and advanced reporting dashboards. This consolidated setup benefits companies without internal marketing support.
“Agencies are like cruise ships. Great amenities, but don’t expect to turn around quickly.”
Agencies can scale quickly, but communication may slow down due to multiple layers of approval or account management. Strategy alignment issues are common if the agency doesn’t specialize in your niche.
3. In-House Pros and Cons
In-house SEO teams offer full-time focus and daily oversight. Salaries in the U.S. range from $72,000–$120,000 for SEO managers and $95,000–$140,000 for technical SEO engineers. Benefits, tools, and training add to the total cost.
This model works well for companies with large websites, multiple product lines, or a constant need for search updates. It reduces reliance on external providers and allows faster collaboration with web and content teams.
“Hiring in-house for SEO is like buying a treadmill. Great if you use it consistently. Expensive if it gathers dust.”
However, hiring takes time and internal output can plateau without new strategies or external input. Training junior staff adds another layer of delay and expense.
Factors That Affect Monthly Costs
Monthly SEO costs vary depending on several factors tied to the complexity and scope of the work. The most common cost drivers are content demands, technical challenges, and the competitiveness of your industry or niche.
1. Content Creation Needs
Content is often the largest recurring cost in SEO. Most freelancers and agencies charge per word, per piece, or as part of a monthly package. As of April 2025, rates for well-optimized blog content typically range from $0.20–$0.50 per word. A standard 1,500-word blog post may cost between $300 and $750.
Interactive content like quizzes, calculators, or comparison tools ranges from $1,500 to $3,000 per asset. These projects require both design and development resources. For larger sites with thousands of indexed pages, full content audits can cost between $5,000 and $10,000 depending on the number of templates, page types, and languages involved.
If video SEO is part of the strategy, budgets often include transcript optimization and schema markup. These services typically consume 15–20% of the total content budget.
“Client: Why is my content budget higher than my design budget? Me: Because Google doesn’t rank you for looking pretty.”
2. Technical Site Fixes
Technical SEO costs vary widely based on your site’s build, age, and underlying frameworks. Simple fixes like updating broken links or improving metadata might fall within a $500–$1,500 range. More complex work—like optimizing JavaScript-heavy pages or cleaning up crawl budget waste—can increase that to $3,000–$5,000.
E-commerce sites with large inventories (10,000+ SKUs) often require schema implementation, canonical tag audits, and pagination fixes. These projects typically fall between $8,000 and $15,000 depending on scale. Platforms like Shopify or Wix may limit back-end access, increasing the hours needed to execute changes.
Older websites with technical debt—such as improper redirects, duplicate content, or mixed HTTP/HTTPS assets—also raise costs. Fixing these issues is often front-loaded in the first 1–2 months of a contract and can quickly consume 40–60% of the initial budget.
3. Level of Competition
The more competitive your industry, the more time and resources are required to rank. In low-competition markets, content production and link-building needs are modest. For example, targeting niche B2B keywords might cost $800–$1,500 per month in content work.
In high-competition verticals like legal services, SaaS, or health, the same effort may cost $2,000–$4,000 monthly just for content. Keyword research and competitive analysis also grow in complexity, increasing total hours billed.
Markets with established players and high domain authority require more backlink acquisition, longer-form content, and frequent updates. National or international targets further increase budget requirements. Local SEO campaigns may range from $1,500 to $3,000/month, while broader campaigns often start at $5,000/month or more.
“Trying to outrank Salesforce for a CRM keyword with a $500 budget is like bringing a spoon to a sword fight.” 🥄⚔️
Costs are rarely static. Each of these variables shifts as your goals, site health, and competition evolve.
Tips to Track ROI and Justify Spending
SEO ROI is tracked using a combination of organic traffic data, keyword movement, conversion rates, and revenue attribution. Most SEO experts rely on tools like Google Analytics 4 (GA4), Google Search Console, Ahrefs, SEMrush, and Looker Studio dashboards to consolidate these metrics.
Organic traffic is the base metric. It shows how many users land on the site from unpaid search results. GA4 tracks this under the “Traffic acquisition” report. Filter by source/medium = “google / organic” to isolate SEO-related visits.
Keyword position changes are tracked using rank monitoring tools. Ahrefs, SEMrush, and SE Ranking allow you to monitor daily or weekly changes across target terms. Most clients track around 20–50 keywords. Movement into the top 3 positions usually correlates with higher click-through rates.
Click-through rate (CTR) is visible in Google Search Console. CTR improvements often result from optimized meta titles, rich snippets, and branded searches. A CTR of 3–5% is typical for positions 3–5. Anything below 1% may indicate poor title optimization or irrelevant queries.
Conversion tracking requires event-based setup in GA4. This includes form submissions, purchases, demo requests, or any action tied to a business goal. Attribution settings should be configured to reflect organic-first touch or last-click models, depending on which part of the funnel is being evaluated.
Revenue contribution from SEO is calculated by segmenting organic source revenue in GA4. For e-commerce businesses, this metric is displayed under “Monetization > Ecommerce purchases.” For service-based businesses, indirect value is estimated through lead conversion rates and customer lifetime value (CLV).
“Client: We got 10,000 clicks but only 2 leads. Me: That’s not SEO underperforming. That’s your form asking for a birth certificate.”
Link profile growth is another measurable component. Tools like Ahrefs track referring domains, domain authority, and link velocity. A steady monthly increase in high-authority backlinks typically aligns with stronger keyword stability and improved rankings.
Reporting frequency is usually monthly. Weekly check-ins are common during the first 90 days of a campaign. Dashboards built in Looker Studio or AgencyAnalytics consolidate traffic, rankings, conversions, and revenue to give a single view of performance.
Most freelancers and consultants charge $300–$1,000/month to maintain and interpret reporting dashboards. Large agencies often bundle this into retainers. Reporting accuracy depends on correct tracking setup—errors here result in misleading ROI figures.
“If you’re measuring SEO ROI without tracking conversions, it’s like judging a book by its spine.” 📚
ROI benchmarks vary by industry. According to recent data, clients spending $3,000–$7,500/month saw measurable ROI within six months in 63% of cases. Common ROI signals include 10–30% growth in organic traffic, 5–15% lift in non-branded rankings, and improved lead quality from top-funnel content.
Frequently Asked Questions about Hiring SEO Experts
These are the questions I hear most often when clients are planning their first SEO hire. Each answer reflects current pricing data and hiring models as of April 9, 2025.
How much does it cost to hire an SEO expert?
Hourly rates for SEO professionals typically range from $50 to $150 for general services. Specialized consultants offering technical SEO, Core Web Vitals remediation, or JavaScript optimization often charge $200–$300 per hour.
Project-based pricing starts at around $500 for one-time audits, with full-service freelance retainers ranging from $1,000–$3,000/month depending on deliverables.
Agencies usually charge $2,500–$7,500/month for standard retainers. Enterprise campaigns with AI-driven content or predictive analytics often start at $10,000/month and rise based on scope.
In-house SEO hires cost $72,000–$140,000 annually in salary alone, excluding tools and training.
“SEO costs less than paid ads—unless you ignore it for five years and try to catch up in one quarter.”
Should I consider a performance-based contract?
Performance-based SEO contracts tie part of the fee (usually 30–50%) to defined metrics like traffic increases, keyword improvements, or conversion lifts. These contracts reduce upfront risk but typically add a 15–25% premium on base pricing due to the performance incentives.
They are more common in agency settings and less so among independent freelancers. Most freelancers prefer flat project fees or hourly billing due to the variability of search algorithms and external dependencies.
These contracts are harder to structure if goals are vague or if the client lacks baseline data for comparison. They are generally not offered for short-term projects.
What if I only have a small budget?
With a $500–$1,000/month budget, hiring a freelancer is the most common path. This budget usually covers a technical audit, optimized metadata, and 1–2 content assets per month.
Basic local SEO campaigns can also fit into this range, especially if the site already has some existing structure. Advanced link building, in-depth content strategy, or technical overhauls are not typically included at this level.
“If your budget is small, aim for consistency, not complexity.”
Contra’s commission-free model allows freelancers to retain their full rate, so more of the budget is spent on actual deliverables rather than platform fees.
Do I need extra tools for SEO tasks?
Most SEO professionals use paid tools like Ahrefs, SEMrush, or Screaming Frog. These cost between $99 and $499 per month. Some freelancers include tool access in their pricing; others ask clients to provide access.
Enterprise-level projects may also involve tools for rank tracking, crawl analysis, or reporting dashboards, which can add another $200–$800/month.
“I once had a client buy five SEO tools, then ask me what a meta title was.” 😅
Free tools like Google Search Console and Google Analytics 4 are essential and used across all project sizes. Open-source tools are available but often require expert configuration, which increases hourly costs.
Final Thoughts on Budget Setting
Budget planning for SEO involves regular re-evaluation. Search engines update frequently, and so do competitors. What worked three months ago may no longer be enough. A consistent review cycle—monthly or quarterly—helps keep strategies aligned with actual performance and shifting priorities.
Goal alignment affects how budgets are used. For example, if the priority moves from traffic growth to lead quality, spending typically shifts from blog content to landing page testing or conversion tracking. Without clear goals, it’s hard to measure if the budget is producing anything useful.
Working with independent freelancers often allows for faster adjustments when goals change mid-project. They can pause deliverables, switch focus areas, or scale back scope without the lag of larger teams. On commission-free platforms like Contra, this flexibility isn’t offset by added platform fees, which helps preserve more of the budget for actual SEO work.
“Client: Can we switch from content to backlinks this month? Freelancer: Sure, I’ll update the scope. Platform: Also, we’re not taking 20% of your payment. Everyone: 🎉”
Freelancers with fewer overhead costs often allow for more granular budgeting. Instead of fixed retainers, it’s possible to break work into smaller projects—like one audit, one page refresh, or one keyword cluster at a time. This is especially useful for startups or teams testing SEO for the first time.
Agencies and in-house teams tend to follow more rigid scopes. Changes require internal sign-off, contract amendments, or new SOWs. For businesses with established processes, this structure may be helpful. For smaller teams, it can create delays or overspending when priorities shift.
“It’s easier to pivot a kayak than a cruise ship. Freelancers are kayaks.” 🛶
Commission-free hiring models also reduce monthly variability. With no surprise deductions or platform fees, teams can more accurately allocate funds to deliverables. On April 9, 2025, the average 20% platform fee translates to $600 on a $3,000/month retainer. That’s equivalent to an extra blog post, a round of keyword research, or two hours of technical fixes.
Like this project
Posted Apr 9, 2025
Setting your budget for SEO? Learn what to expect when hiring SEO experts, from pricing models to ROI tracking and cost factors that impact results.
Hire SEO Specialist or DIY? The Honest Cost-Benefit Analysis
10 Signs Your Business Desperately Needs to Hire an SEO Expert
Hire an SEO Expert: 5 Questions to Ask Yourself First
The Algorithm Update Question: Testing Your SEO Expert's Adaptability