Don't Build Blindly: 5 Steps to Set Clear Website Goals for Maximum ROI
Ralph Sanchez
Don't Build Blindly: 5 Steps to Set Clear Website Goals for Maximum ROI
Why Vague Goals Lead to Website Failure
The Problem with 'Just Needing a Website'
Connecting Website Goals to Business Objectives
Step 1: Define Your Primary Business Objective
Common Website Objectives
Choosing Your North Star Metric
Step 2: Identify and Understand Your Target Audience
Creating User Personas
Mapping the User Journey
Step 3: Set SMART Website Goals
Specific: From Vague to Clear
Measurable: How You'll Track Success
Achievable, Relevant, and Time-bound
Step 4: Map Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) to Your Goals
What are KPIs?
Examples of Goal-Oriented KPIs
Step 5: Translate Your Goals into Website Features
Feature Prioritization
Creating a Project Brief
Conclusion
References
Don't Build Blindly: 5 Steps to Set Clear Website Goals for Maximum ROI
Before you write a single line of code or choose a color palette, the most important step in any website project is defining what you want to achieve. Without clear goals, your website is just a digital brochure with no purpose. This guide will walk you through five essential steps to set strategic website goals, which will inform how you'll build your site and determine what a WordPress site really costs. This foundational work ensures that every decision, from design to hiring a developer, is aimed at delivering a measurable return on investment.
Think about it this way: You wouldn't start building a house without blueprints. You wouldn't launch a product without knowing who'll buy it. So why do so many businesses rush into website development without a clear plan? The truth is, when you hire WordPress developers or any web professional without defined goals, you're essentially asking them to guess what success looks like for your business.
Why Vague Goals Lead to Website Failure
Let me paint you a familiar picture. A business owner decides they need a website. They hire someone to build it. Six months and thousands of dollars later, they have a beautiful site that... doesn't really do anything for their business. Sound familiar?
This happens more often than you'd think. The culprit? Starting with vague, undefined goals that sound good but mean nothing. "We need to look professional." "We want to reach more customers." "Everyone has a website, so we need one too."
These aren't goals. They're wishes. And wishes don't drive business results.
The Problem with 'Just Needing a Website'
When your only goal is "I need a website," you're setting yourself up for disappointment. Here's what typically happens:
Your designer asks what you want. You say something like "make it modern and professional." They create something that looks nice. You launch it. Then... crickets.
Why? Because a pretty website without purpose is like a sports car without an engine. It might look impressive, but it won't take you anywhere.
Real websites need real goals. Do you want people to call you? Buy your products? Sign up for your newsletter? Each of these requires different design elements, different content, and different functionality. Without knowing what you want visitors to do, you can't guide them to do it.
I've seen businesses spend $10,000 on a website only to realize it doesn't have a contact form in the right place. Or an e-commerce site that makes checkout so complicated that customers abandon their carts. These aren't design failures. They're goal-setting failures.
Connecting Website Goals to Business Objectives
Your website isn't a standalone entity. It's a tool in your business toolkit. Just like you wouldn't buy a hammer without knowing you need to drive nails, you shouldn't build a website without knowing what business problem it solves.
Start by asking yourself: What keeps me up at night about my business? Maybe it's:
Not enough customers know about your services
You're drowning in phone calls for basic questions
Your sales team spends too much time on unqualified leads
Competitors are eating your market share online
Your website should directly address these pain points. If you're losing customers to competitors, your site needs to showcase why you're better. If you're overwhelmed with basic inquiries, your site needs a robust FAQ section.
Every element on your website should trace back to a business need. That hero image? It should communicate your value proposition. That blog? It should establish your expertise and improve search rankings. That chatbot? It should qualify leads before they reach your sales team.
When your website goals align with your business objectives, magic happens. Instead of a digital brochure, you get a 24/7 sales machine.
Step 1: Define Your Primary Business Objective
Now we're getting somewhere. Before you think about colors, fonts, or fancy animations, you need to answer one critical question: What is the single most important thing this website should do for my business?
Notice I said "single." Not five things. Not ten things. One thing.
Why just one? Because when everything is a priority, nothing is a priority. Your website needs a North Star - a primary objective that guides every decision you make.
Common Website Objectives
Let's look at the most common primary objectives businesses choose:
Generate high-quality leads: Perfect for B2B companies and service providers. Your website becomes a lead-capture machine, turning visitors into potential customers your sales team can contact.
Increase online sales: The obvious choice for e-commerce businesses. Every element focuses on moving visitors through the purchase journey as smoothly as possible.
Establish industry authority: Ideal for consultants, thought leaders, and businesses in competitive markets. Your website showcases expertise through content, case studies, and credentials.
Provide customer support: Great for businesses with complex products or services. Your website becomes a self-service hub that reduces support tickets and improves customer satisfaction.
Build a community: Works well for brands with passionate customers. Your website becomes a gathering place that strengthens customer loyalty and creates brand advocates.
Each objective requires a completely different approach. A lead-generation site needs prominent contact forms and compelling calls-to-action. An authority site needs in-depth content and social proof. A support site needs comprehensive documentation and easy navigation.
Choosing Your North Star Metric
Once you've identified your primary objective, you need to choose your North Star metric - the one number that tells you if your website is succeeding.
For lead generation, your North Star might be qualified leads per month. Not just any leads - qualified ones that match your ideal customer profile. A hundred tire-kickers aren't worth one serious buyer.
For e-commerce, it's usually revenue, but it could be average order value or customer lifetime value. A site that generates fewer but higher-value sales might be more successful than one with lots of small transactions.
For authority building, consider metrics like email subscribers or content shares. These show that people value your expertise enough to want more of it.
Your North Star metric becomes your decision-making filter. Considering a new feature? Ask yourself: Will this improve our North Star metric? If not, it's probably not worth the time and money.
Remember, you can have secondary goals. But they should support, not compete with, your primary objective. An e-commerce site can build authority through blog content, but only if that content ultimately drives sales.
Step 2: Identify and Understand Your Target Audience
Here's a truth that might sting: Your website isn't for you. It's for your customers. And if you don't know who they are, what they want, and how they think, you're building blind.
I've seen gorgeous websites fail because they spoke to the wrong audience. Like a law firm website full of legal jargon when their clients just want to know "Can you help me with my divorce?" Or a tech startup using simple language when their audience wants technical specifications.
Your audience determines everything. The words you use. The images you choose. The features you include. Even the buttons you design.
Creating User Personas
User personas aren't just marketing fluff. They're your north star for making decisions. Instead of guessing what might work, you can ask, "What would Sarah the Small Business Owner want to see here?"
Here's how to create personas that actually help:
Start with demographics, but don't stop there. Age and income tell you something, but not enough. Dig deeper. What are their goals? What frustrates them? What does success look like to them?
Let's build a real example. Say you're a financial advisor targeting pre-retirees:
Meet Robert, 58, IT Manager
Worried he hasn't saved enough for retirement
Overwhelmed by investment options
Doesn't trust financial advisors (thinks they're all salespeople)
Researches everything online before making decisions
Values clear, jargon-free explanations
Now you know Robert needs proof you're trustworthy. Educational content that explains complex topics simply. Testimonials from people like him. A clear process that shows you're an advisor, not a salesperson.
Create 2-3 personas maximum. More than that and you'll lose focus. These personas should represent 80% of your ideal customers. The other 20%? They'll adapt to a site built for your core audience.
Mapping the User Journey
Once you know who your users are, map out how they'll move through your site. This isn't about your sales process. It's about their buying process.
Think of it like planning a road trip. You need to know:
Where they're starting (their current problem or need)
Where they want to go (their ideal solution)
What stops they'll make along the way (information they need)
What might make them turn back (concerns or objections)
For Robert the pre-retiree, his journey might look like this:
Awareness: "I'm worried about retirement" - He searches for retirement planning tips
Research: "What are my options?" - He reads about different investment strategies
Evaluation: "Who can I trust?" - He looks for credentials and reviews
Decision: "Is this the right advisor?" - He wants to talk without commitment
Action: "Let's do this" - He's ready to schedule a consultation
Each stage needs different content and features. Awareness stage? Blog posts about retirement planning basics. Evaluation stage? Case studies and advisor bios. Decision stage? A low-pressure "ask questions" form.
The magic happens when you remove friction from this journey. Every unnecessary click, every confusing menu, every piece of jargon is a roadblock that might send them to your competitor.
Step 3: Set SMART Website Goals
Now comes the part where we turn your wishes into actual goals. You've probably heard of SMART goals before. Maybe you've even rolled your eyes at another acronym. But stick with me - this framework transforms vague hopes into achievable targets.
SMART stands for Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, and Time-bound. It's the difference between "I want to get in shape" and "I'll run a 5K in under 30 minutes by March 1st." One is a wish. The other is a goal you can actually achieve.
Specific: From Vague to Clear
Let's start with the S in SMART. Specific goals tell you exactly what success looks like. No interpretation needed. No guessing games.
Watch this transformation:
Vague: "Get more leads"
Specific: "Increase marketing qualified leads from our contact form"
See the difference? The specific version tells you:
What kind of leads (marketing qualified, not just any email address)
Where they come from (the contact form, not phone calls or walk-ins)
What action to focus on (increase, not just maintain)
Here's another example:
Vague: "Improve user experience"
Specific: "Reduce checkout abandonment rate on mobile devices"
The specific version points to an exact problem (checkout abandonment) on a specific platform (mobile). Now you know what to fix.
Being specific forces you to think through what you really want. "More traffic" sounds good until you realize you want qualified traffic that converts, not random visitors who bounce immediately.
Measurable: How You'll Track Success
The M in SMART is where rubber meets road. If you can't measure it, you can't improve it. Period.
Let's build on our specific examples:
"Increase marketing qualified leads from our contact form by 20%"
"Reduce checkout abandonment rate on mobile devices from 68% to 50%"
Now we have numbers. Real, trackable numbers. Not "better" or "more" but actual percentages you can monitor in Google Analytics or your CRM.
But here's where people mess up: They pick metrics they can't actually measure. Before you set a measurable goal, make sure you have:
The tools to track it (analytics software, CRM, etc.)
A baseline to measure against (current performance)
A clear definition of what counts (what makes a lead "qualified"?)
Without these three things, your measurable goal is just another wish with numbers attached.
Achievable, Relevant, and Time-bound
The last three letters of SMART work together to keep your goals grounded in reality.
Achievable means possible, not easy. If you're getting 10 leads per month, jumping to 1,000 next month isn't achievable. But 15? 20? That's challenging but possible. Push yourself, but don't set yourself up for failure.
Relevant ties back to your primary business objective. Remember that North Star metric we talked about? Every goal should move you closer to it. If your North Star is revenue, a goal about social media followers better connect to sales somehow.
Time-bound creates urgency. "Someday" never comes. "By March 31st" is marked on the calendar. But be realistic about timelines. SEO improvements take months. A new contact form can show results in weeks.
Here's what our complete SMART goals look like:
"Increase marketing qualified leads from our contact form by 20% within the next 90 days"
"Reduce checkout abandonment rate on mobile devices from 68% to 50% by the end of Q2"
These goals tell you what to do, how to measure success, and when to celebrate (or pivot if things aren't working).
Step 4: Map Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) to Your Goals
Goals tell you where you're going. KPIs tell you if you're getting there. Think of them as your website's vital signs - the numbers that reveal health or illness before symptoms appear.
Too many businesses set goals and then wait months to see if they worked. That's like driving cross-country without checking your gas gauge. KPIs give you real-time feedback so you can adjust course before it's too late.
What are KPIs?
KPIs are the specific, quantifiable measures that track your progress toward a goal. They're not the goal itself - they're the breadcrumbs that show you're on the right path.
Let's say your goal is to increase online sales by 30% this quarter. That's great, but you won't know if you're succeeding until the quarter ends. KPIs fill in the gaps:
Weekly sales revenue (are you on pace?)
Conversion rate (are more visitors buying?)
Average order value (are people spending more?)
Cart abandonment rate (where are you losing sales?)
Each KPI tells part of the story. Together, they paint a complete picture of what's working and what isn't.
The best KPIs share three characteristics:
They're leading indicators - They predict future success, not just report past performance
They're actionable - When they change, you know what to do
They're simple - Anyone on your team can understand them
Examples of Goal-Oriented KPIs
Different goals need different KPIs. Let's look at real examples for common website objectives:
For Lead Generation Goals:
Conversion rate (visitors to leads)
Cost per lead (if you're running ads)
Lead quality score (are they your ideal customer?)
Form abandonment rate (how many start but don't finish?)
Time to contact (how quickly you follow up)
A financial advisor might discover their conversion rate is great, but their form abandonment is high. The KPI reveals the problem: Their form asks for too much information upfront.
For E-commerce Goals:
Add-to-cart rate
Checkout completion rate
Customer lifetime value
Return visitor rate
Product page dwell time
An online clothing store might see high add-to-cart rates but low checkout completion. The KPIs point to a checkout process problem, not a product problem.
For Brand Awareness Goals:
Organic traffic growth
Social shares per article
Email subscriber growth rate
Brand mention tracking
Content engagement rate
A B2B software company might find their traffic is growing but engagement is dropping. The KPIs suggest they're attracting the wrong audience - time to refine their content strategy.
The key is choosing KPIs that directly connect to your SMART goals. If your goal is about mobile checkout abandonment, tracking desktop performance won't help. Stay focused on what matters.
Step 5: Translate Your Goals into Website Features
This is where strategy becomes reality. You've set clear goals. You know your audience. You've defined success metrics. Now it's time to build a website that actually delivers on all that planning.
Here's the thing: Every feature costs money. Not just to build, but to maintain, update, and optimize. The businesses that succeed online aren't the ones with the most features. They're the ones with the right features.
Feature Prioritization
Think of your website features like packing for a trip. You could bring everything you own, but you'll end up with heavy bags and still forget something important. Better to pack what you actually need.
Start with your primary goal and work backward. What features are absolutely essential to achieve that goal? These are your must-haves. Everything else goes into two buckets: should-haves and nice-to-haves.
Let's see this in action for different primary goals:
Lead Generation Site Must-Haves:
Prominent contact forms on key pages
Clear value proposition above the fold
Trust signals (testimonials, certifications)
Lead magnets (free guides, calculators)
Thank you pages for conversion tracking
Should-haves: Live chat, case studies, FAQ section Nice-to-haves: Client portal, advanced calculators, video testimonials
E-commerce Site Must-Haves:
Intuitive product search and filters
High-quality product images with zoom
Simple checkout process
Multiple payment options
Mobile-responsive design
Should-haves: Wishlist feature, product reviews, size guides Nice-to-haves: AR try-on features, loyalty program, gift wrapping
Notice how features that seem essential for one goal become optional for another? That e-commerce site needs product reviews. The lead generation site? Not so much.
The 80/20 rule applies here: 80% of your results will come from 20% of your features. Focus on nailing that crucial 20% before adding bells and whistles.
Creating a Project Brief
Now you need to package all this strategic thinking into something useful - a project brief that turns your vision into reality.
A good project brief is like a recipe. It tells your developer (or yourself, if you're DIY-ing) exactly what ingredients you need and how to combine them. Without it, you're asking them to cook dinner with whatever's in the fridge.
Your project brief should include:
Business Context
What your business does
Who your competitors are
What makes you different
Website Goals
Primary objective (with your SMART goal)
Secondary objectives
North Star metric
Target Audience
User personas with key characteristics
User journey maps
Pain points your site will address
Required Features
Must-have functionality
Should-have functionality
Nice-to-have functionality
Success Metrics
KPIs you'll track
Current baseline numbers
Target numbers and timeline
Technical Requirements
Platform preferences (WordPress, Shopify, etc.)
Integration needs (CRM, email marketing, etc.)
Hosting and security requirements
Design Direction
Brand guidelines
Sites you like (and why)
Sites you don't like (and why)
Budget and Timeline
Total budget range
Launch deadline
Any important milestones
This brief becomes your contract with reality. It forces you to make decisions upfront when you're thinking clearly, not in the heat of development when every feature seems critical.
Share this brief with potential developers before they quote. It'll save everyone time and ensure you get accurate proposals. More importantly, it keeps your project focused on what matters - achieving your business goals.
Conclusion
Building a website without clear goals is like sailing without a destination. You might enjoy the journey, but you'll probably end up lost at sea. The five steps we've covered transform website development from an expensive gamble into a strategic investment.
Let's recap what you've learned:
Define one primary business objective - Your North Star that guides every decision
Know your target audience deeply - Build for them, not for yourself
Set SMART goals - Specific, measurable targets that drive real results
Choose KPIs that matter - Track progress, not just activity
Match features to goals - Every element should earn its place
The businesses that win online aren't necessarily the ones with the biggest budgets or the flashiest designs. They're the ones that know exactly what they want their website to achieve and build accordingly.
Your next step? Block out two hours this week to work through these five steps for your own website. Start with your primary business objective. Be honest about what really matters to your bottom line. Then work through each step methodically.
Remember: A website with purpose beats a pretty website every time. When you're clear on your goals, every decision becomes easier. Every dollar spent becomes an investment. Every visitor becomes an opportunity.
Don't build blindly. Build with intention. Your future self (and your bank account) will thank you.
References
Like this project
Posted Jul 6, 2025
A new website is an investment. Ensure it pays off by setting clear, measurable goals from the start. Learn our 5-step framework for defining success.
