20 Must-Ask Interview Questions for Hiring an SEO Consultant
Gordon Ibarra
20 Must-Ask Interview Questions for Hiring an SEO Consultant
Questions About Their Approach and Strategy
1. How would you describe your overall SEO philosophy?
2. Based on our website, what do you see as our biggest SEO opportunities and challenges?
3. How do you stay up-to-date with Google's algorithm changes?
4. How do you approach keyword research and user intent?
5. What is your process for conducting an SEO audit?
Questions About Technical Expertise and Experience
6. Can you describe a challenging technical SEO issue you've solved?
7. What is your experience with website migrations?
8. How do you approach link building? What kind of links do you consider valuable?
9. Which SEO tools do you prefer and why?
10. How do you factor user experience (UX) and site speed into your strategy?
Questions About Reporting and Communication
11. How do you measure the success of an SEO campaign?
12. What would your typical monthly report look like?
13. How do you handle a situation where results are not meeting expectations?
14. How would you collaborate with our content and development teams?
15. Can you provide examples of past work or case studies?
Questions to Uncover Red Flags
16. Can you guarantee a #1 ranking on Google?
17. How long will it take to see results?
18. Do you have a 'special relationship' with Google?
19. What are your thoughts on AI-generated content for SEO?
20. What questions do you have for me?
References
20 Must-Ask Interview Questions for Hiring an SEO Consultant
The interview is your opportunity to dig deeper than a resume or portfolio and truly assess an SEO consultant's expertise and strategic thinking. Asking the right questions is critical to finding a partner who can deliver real results. This list of questions will help you evaluate candidates effectively.
Having a well-written project brief is the first step to attract qualified candidates to interview, and being prepared for the interview is the next. You'll also want to know the red flags to watch out for during these conversations.
Questions About Their Approach and Strategy
These questions are designed to understand how the consultant thinks about SEO strategically and how they would approach your specific business.
1. How would you describe your overall SEO philosophy?
This opening question sets the tone for the entire interview. You're looking for someone who sees SEO as more than just keywords and backlinks. The best consultants understand that SEO is about creating value for users while making that value discoverable by search engines.
Listen for answers that prioritize the user, adhere to white-hat practices, and integrate SEO with broader business goals. A consultant who talks about "gaming the system" or focuses solely on technical tricks is missing the bigger picture. Great SEO consultants understand that sustainable success comes from aligning search optimization with genuine user needs.
Pay attention to whether they mention the importance of content quality, user experience, and ethical practices. If they immediately jump into technical jargon without addressing the human element, that's worth noting.
2. Based on our website, what do you see as our biggest SEO opportunities and challenges?
This question separates the prepared candidates from those who are winging it. A serious consultant will have already spent time analyzing your website before the interview. They should be able to point out specific issues and opportunities they've noticed.
Good answers might include observations about your site structure, content gaps, technical issues, or competitive positioning. They might mention things like missing meta descriptions, slow page load times, or opportunities to target specific keyword clusters. The specificity of their answer tells you how thoroughly they've prepared.
If they give generic answers that could apply to any website, that's a red flag. You want someone who has taken the time to understand your unique situation.
3. How do you stay up-to-date with Google's algorithm changes?
SEO changes constantly. Google makes hundreds of updates each year, and staying current is essential for success. A good consultant should mention following reputable industry publications, attending webinars, and being part of SEO communities.
Look for specific sources they mention. Do they follow Google's official channels? Are they part of professional SEO communities? Do they test changes on their own projects? The best consultants are curious and proactive about learning.
Be wary of anyone who claims they "just know" or relies on outdated information. SEO myths persist for years after they've been debunked, and you need someone who can separate fact from fiction.
4. How do you approach keyword research and user intent?
Keyword research has evolved far beyond finding high-volume search terms. Modern SEO requires understanding the why behind searches, not just the what. Listen for a nuanced approach that goes beyond just search volume to consider the user's goal behind the search query.
Strong candidates will discuss different types of search intent: informational, navigational, commercial, and transactional. They should explain how they map keywords to different stages of the customer journey. They might mention tools they use, but more importantly, they should describe their thought process.
Watch out for consultants who focus only on search volume or keyword difficulty. While these metrics matter, they're just part of the picture. The best keyword strategies align search terms with business goals and user needs.
5. What is your process for conducting an SEO audit?
An SEO audit is often the first major deliverable from a consultant, so understanding their process is crucial. They should outline a structured process that covers technical, on-page, and off-page factors.
A comprehensive audit process might include crawling the site for technical issues, analyzing content quality and relevance, reviewing backlink profiles, checking mobile optimization, and assessing site speed. They should also mention competitor analysis and identifying quick wins versus long-term opportunities.
The depth of their answer reveals their expertise. Do they use a checklist approach, or do they customize their audits based on the specific business? Can they explain how they prioritize issues? A thoughtful, detailed response shows they've done this before and understand what matters most.
Questions About Technical Expertise and Experience
These questions probe their hands-on skills and experience with the technical aspects of SEO.
6. Can you describe a challenging technical SEO issue you've solved?
This question tests their problem-solving skills and technical depth. Look for a clear explanation of the problem, their process, and the result. The best answers include specific details about the challenge, the steps they took to diagnose it, and the outcome.
Maybe they dealt with a complex canonicalization issue, solved a JavaScript rendering problem, or fixed a site architecture that was preventing proper crawling. The technical details matter less than their ability to explain the issue clearly and show their problem-solving approach.
If they can't provide a specific example or their explanation is vague, that's concerning. Every experienced SEO consultant has war stories about technical challenges they've overcome.
7. What is your experience with website migrations?
Even if you're not planning a migration, this is a complex task that reveals a consultant's level of technical expertise. Migrations are where SEO can go catastrophically wrong, so experience here demonstrates advanced skills.
Look for mentions of redirect mapping, preserving link equity, maintaining URL structures, and pre-launch testing. They should discuss the importance of benchmarking before migration and monitoring closely afterward. Experience with different types of migrations (platform changes, domain changes, HTTPS migrations) is a plus.
A consultant who has successfully managed migrations understands the stakes involved and the attention to detail required. If they've never done one, that doesn't disqualify them, but it does indicate their experience level.
8. How do you approach link building? What kind of links do you consider valuable?
Link building remains crucial for SEO success, but the approach matters enormously. A red flag would be any mention of buying links or using automated schemes. Look for a focus on earning high-quality, relevant backlinks.
Good consultants talk about creating link-worthy content, building relationships with relevant websites, and earning links naturally. They might mention tactics like guest posting on reputable sites, creating valuable resources that attract links, or digital PR strategies.
The emphasis should be on quality over quantity. They should understand that one link from a highly relevant, authoritative site is worth more than dozens from low-quality directories. If they promise hundreds of links quickly, run the other way.
9. Which SEO tools do you prefer and why?
While the specific tools are less important than the skill in using them, this shows their familiarity with the industry-standard software. Most professionals use a combination of tools for different purposes.
They might mention Google Search Console and Analytics as essentials, along with specialized tools for keyword research, technical audits, backlink analysis, and rank tracking. What matters is that they can explain why they use each tool and what insights they gain from them.
Be cautious of consultants who rely on a single tool for everything or those who seem unfamiliar with the major platforms. While you don't need someone who uses every tool available, they should have a thoughtful toolkit that matches their approach.
10. How do you factor user experience (UX) and site speed into your strategy?
A modern SEO approach must consider UX signals. Their answer should reflect an understanding that a good user experience is crucial for rankings. Google has made it clear that page experience is a ranking factor, including metrics like Core Web Vitals.
Listen for mentions of mobile optimization, page load speed, interactivity, and visual stability. They should understand that technical performance directly impacts user satisfaction and search rankings. Good consultants see UX and SEO as complementary, not competing priorities.
If they dismiss UX as "not really SEO" or seem unfamiliar with Core Web Vitals, that's outdated thinking. Modern SEO requires a holistic view of what makes a good web experience.
Questions About Reporting and Communication
These questions help you understand how they will measure success, communicate progress, and work with your team.
11. How do you measure the success of an SEO campaign?
Their answer should focus on business-centric KPIs like leads and conversions, not just vanity metrics like traffic or rankings. While rankings and traffic matter, they're means to an end, not the end itself.
A thoughtful consultant will ask about your business goals first, then explain how they'll track progress toward those goals. They might discuss setting up proper conversion tracking, analyzing user behavior, and connecting SEO performance to revenue or lead generation.
Watch out for consultants who only talk about ranking for certain keywords or increasing traffic. Without context about quality and conversions, these metrics are meaningless. The best SEO drives business results, not just numbers on a dashboard.
12. What would your typical monthly report look like?
A good report should be more than a data dump. It should provide insights, analysis, and a summary of activities and next steps. The best reports tell a story about progress toward goals.
They should mention including an executive summary that non-technical stakeholders can understand, detailed metrics that show progress, analysis of what's working and what isn't, and clear next steps. Visual elements like charts and graphs help communicate complex data simply.
If they talk about sending automated reports straight from tools without any analysis or context, that's not enough. You're hiring them for their expertise and insights, not just to forward data you could access yourself.
13. How do you handle a situation where results are not meeting expectations?
This question reveals character as much as competence. Look for honesty, a willingness to analyze what's not working, and a proactive approach to pivoting strategy. SEO doesn't always go according to plan, and you need someone who can adapt.
Strong answers acknowledge that setbacks happen and focus on diagnosis and solutions. They might talk about diving deeper into analytics, reassessing the competitive landscape, or adjusting the strategy based on new information. The key is that they take ownership and have a process for improvement.
Beware of consultants who blame external factors without taking any responsibility or those who seem defensive about this question. You want a partner who can handle challenges professionally.
14. How would you collaborate with our content and development teams?
This assesses their communication and teamwork skills, which are crucial for implementing SEO recommendations. SEO doesn't happen in isolation; it requires coordination across teams.
Look for answers that show respect for other disciplines and an understanding of how to communicate technical requirements clearly. They might discuss creating SEO guidelines for content creators, working with developers on technical implementations, or facilitating knowledge transfer to your team.
If they seem dismissive of other teams or expect to work in isolation, that's a problem. Successful SEO requires buy-in and collaboration across your organization.
15. Can you provide examples of past work or case studies?
Ask for specific examples of results they've achieved for clients, ideally in a similar industry to yours. While they may not be able to share client names due to confidentiality, they should be able to discuss the challenges, strategies, and outcomes.
Pay attention to how they present their successes. Do they take all the credit, or do they acknowledge the team effort involved? Can they explain not just what happened but why their approach worked? The best case studies show strategic thinking, not just lucky breaks.
If they can't provide any examples or their stories seem vague and unverifiable, proceed with caution. Experienced consultants should have a track record they can discuss.
Questions to Uncover Red Flags
These final questions are designed to expose any potential red flags or outdated practices.
16. Can you guarantee a #1 ranking on Google?
The correct answer is no. Any guarantee of specific rankings is a major red flag. Google's algorithm considers hundreds of factors, competition is constantly changing, and no one can control search results.
A professional consultant will explain that while they can improve your visibility and traffic, specific ranking guarantees are impossible and unethical. They might discuss realistic expectations and focus on overall improvement rather than specific positions.
If someone guarantees rankings, especially quickly, they're either dishonest or dangerously naive. Either way, they're not someone you want handling your SEO.
17. How long will it take to see results?
A trustworthy consultant will explain that SEO is a long-term strategy and results can take several months, depending on various factors. They should avoid promising quick fixes. SEO is a marathon, not a sprint.
Good answers acknowledge that some improvements (like fixing technical issues) can show results quickly, while others (like building authority) take time. They might discuss seeing initial improvements in 3-6 months, with more significant results taking 6-12 months or longer.
Anyone promising dramatic results in weeks is likely using risky tactics that could harm your site long-term. Patience is essential in SEO, and your consultant should set realistic expectations.
18. Do you have a 'special relationship' with Google?
This is a classic red flag. No one has an inside track with Google's algorithms. While some agencies are Google Partners for advertising, this has nothing to do with organic search rankings.
A honest consultant will laugh at this question and explain that Google doesn't give anyone special treatment in organic search. They might mention that they follow Google's guidelines and best practices, but that's available to everyone.
If someone claims special access or insider knowledge, they're trying to deceive you. Google's algorithm treats all sites equally based on their merit.
19. What are your thoughts on AI-generated content for SEO?
Their answer should be nuanced, discussing the importance of high-quality, helpful content, whether AI-assisted or not, and the potential pitfalls of purely automated content. This question tests their understanding of current trends and Google's stance on content quality.
Look for a balanced view that acknowledges AI as a tool that can assist with content creation while emphasizing that human oversight, fact-checking, and adding unique value remain essential. They should understand that Google cares about content quality and helpfulness, not how it was created.
If they're either completely against AI or suggest flooding your site with automated content, they're missing the nuance of modern content strategy.
20. What questions do you have for me?
A great consultant will have thoughtful questions about your business goals, target audience, and past marketing efforts, showing genuine interest and strategic thinking. This is their chance to show they're evaluating fit just as much as you are.
Good questions might include asking about your target customers, your competitive advantages, your content resources, or your past SEO experiences. They should be trying to understand your business context to determine if they can genuinely help.
If they have no questions or only ask about budget and timeline, that suggests they're more interested in closing a deal than understanding your needs. The best consultants are selective about their clients and want to ensure mutual success.
Finding the right SEO consultant requires asking tough questions and listening carefully to the answers. Use this guide to conduct thorough interviews that reveal not just technical competence but also strategic thinking, communication skills, and ethical standards. The right consultant will welcome these questions and provide thoughtful, detailed responses that demonstrate their expertise and professionalism.
Remember, you're not just hiring someone to improve rankings. You're choosing a partner who will help grow your business through organic search. Take the time to ask these questions, evaluate the responses carefully, and trust your instincts about who will be the best fit for your organization.
References
Like this project
Posted Jun 15, 2025
Don't hire the wrong SEO consultant. This guide provides 20 essential interview questions covering strategy, technical skills, and reporting to help you vet candidates and find an expert.
