10 Common Mistakes to Avoid When Hiring Shopify Developers (and How to Fix Them)
Ralph Sanchez
10 Common Mistakes to Avoid When Hiring Shopify Developers (and How to Fix Them)
Mistake 1: Not Clearly Defining Project Requirements & Scope
The Problem
The Fix
Mistake 2: Focusing Solely on Price, Not Value
The Problem
The Fix
Mistake 3: Neglecting to Thoroughly Check Portfolios and Past Work
The Problem
The Fix
Mistake 4: Not Verifying References or Checking Reviews
The Problem
The Fix
Mistake 5: Underestimating the Importance of Communication Skills
The Problem
The Fix
Mistake 6: Ignoring Relevant Shopify-Specific Experience
The Problem
The Fix
Mistake 7: Not Having a Clear Contract or Agreement
The Problem
The Fix
Mistake 8: Rushing the Hiring Process
The Problem
The Fix
Mistake 9: Disregarding Ongoing Support and Maintenance Needs
The Problem
The Fix
Mistake 10: Not Knowing Your Target Audience
The Problem
The Fix
Conclusion: Hiring Smarter for Shopify Success
References
10 Common Mistakes to Avoid When Hiring Shopify Developers (and How to Fix Them)
Hiring a Shopify developer can transform your e-commerce business from a basic online store into a conversion powerhouse. But here's the thing - making the wrong hiring decision can cost you time, money, and potentially damage your brand. After properly onboarding your developer and evaluating a Shopify developer's portfolio, you might think you're all set. But there are still plenty of pitfalls that can derail your project before it even begins.
The good news? Most of these mistakes are completely avoidable when you know what to watch for. Whether you're building your first Shopify store or redesigning an existing one, understanding these common hiring mistakes will save you from headaches down the road. And if you want to skip some of the guesswork entirely, you can access vetted Shopify professionals on Contra who've already been screened for quality and reliability.
Mistake 1: Not Clearly Defining Project Requirements & Scope
The Problem
Picture this: You hire a developer with vague instructions like "make my store look modern" or "improve the checkout process." Three weeks later, you're looking at a design that's nothing like what you imagined, and the developer is asking for more money to make changes. Sound familiar?
When you don't provide detailed specifications for design, functionality, and deliverables, you're essentially asking someone to read your mind. This leads to constant back-and-forth, scope creep, and a final product that misses the mark entirely. Your developer might be talented, but they're not psychic.
The Fix
Before you even start looking for a developer, sit down and create a comprehensive project brief. This isn't just a wish list - it's your roadmap to success. Include specific details about your goals, target audience, must-have features, design preferences, and expected outcomes.
For example, instead of saying "improve checkout," write something like: "Implement a one-page checkout with guest option, Apple Pay integration, and abandoned cart recovery emails triggered after 2 hours." The more specific you are, the better results you'll get. Include screenshots of designs you like, list specific apps you need integrated, and outline any unique functionality your business requires.
Mistake 2: Focusing Solely on Price, Not Value
The Problem
We get it - budgets are tight, especially for small businesses. But choosing the developer with the lowest hourly rate is like buying the cheapest parachute. Sure, you saved money upfront, but what happens when things go wrong?
Bargain-basement developers often deliver poor quality work, miss deadlines, or worse - disappear halfway through the project. You might save $20 per hour initially, but when you have to hire someone else to fix their mistakes, you'll end up spending double.
The Fix
Think of hiring a developer as an investment, not an expense. Look beyond the hourly rate and consider the total value they bring. An experienced developer charging $100/hour who completes your project in 40 hours costs the same as a $50/hour developer who takes 80 hours - except you get your store launched faster.
Evaluate candidates based on their portfolio quality, client reviews, communication skills, and relevant experience. A developer who's built 50+ successful Shopify stores will work more efficiently and avoid costly mistakes that a beginner might make. Remember, expertise commands a fair rate for good reason.
Mistake 3: Neglecting to Thoroughly Check Portfolios and Past Work
The Problem
Taking a developer at their word without verifying their actual work is like buying a car without test driving it. Anyone can claim they're a "Shopify expert" or have "10 years of experience." But can they prove it?
Many business owners make the mistake of having a quick chat with a developer and hiring them based on personality alone. While good rapport matters, it doesn't guarantee technical competence or design skills.
The Fix
Always request and carefully review portfolios before making any decisions. Don't just glance at screenshots - visit the live Shopify stores they've built. Click through the pages, test the checkout process, and see how the site performs on mobile devices.
Look for projects similar to what you need. If you're selling fashion accessories, a developer who's only built stores for industrial equipment might not be your best bet. Ask specific questions about their contributions to each project. Did they handle the entire build or just make minor tweaks? Understanding their actual involvement helps you gauge their true capabilities.
Mistake 4: Not Verifying References or Checking Reviews
The Problem
Skipping reference checks is like going on a blind date without asking any mutual friends about the person. You're taking a huge risk based on limited information. Even developers with impressive portfolios might have left a trail of unhappy clients due to poor communication or reliability issues.
The Fix
Always ask for at least three client references and actually contact them. Don't just send a generic email - pick up the phone. Ask specific questions about the developer's communication style, ability to meet deadlines, problem-solving skills, and how they handled unexpected challenges.
Look for reviews on reputable platforms and pay attention to patterns. One negative review might be an outlier, but if multiple clients mention the same issues, that's a red flag. Ask references if they would hire the developer again - a moment of hesitation in their answer tells you everything you need to know.
Mistake 5: Underestimating the Importance of Communication Skills
The Problem
You've found a developer with incredible technical skills and a stunning portfolio. But every email takes three reads to understand, they rarely respond within 24 hours, and explaining your vision feels like speaking different languages. This communication gap will turn your project into a frustrating nightmare.
Poor communication leads to misunderstood requirements, delayed timelines, and a final product that doesn't match your expectations. Technical brilliance means nothing if the developer can't understand what you need or explain their process clearly.
The Fix
Test communication skills during your initial interactions. Pay attention to how quickly they respond, whether they ask clarifying questions, and if they can explain technical concepts in simple terms. A good developer should make you feel heard and understood, not confused and frustrated.
During interviews, ask them to explain a complex Shopify feature in layman's terms. If they struggle or resort to jargon, imagine how difficult the entire project will be. Look for developers who are proactive communicators - they should update you regularly without being asked and flag potential issues before they become problems.
Mistake 6: Ignoring Relevant Shopify-Specific Experience
The Problem
Hiring a general web developer for your Shopify store is like asking a car mechanic to fix your boat. Sure, they understand engines, but boats have unique systems and requirements. Shopify has its own ecosystem, including Liquid templating language, specific app integrations, and platform limitations that general developers won't understand.
A developer without Shopify experience might build something that looks good but violates platform best practices, causing slow load times, checkout issues, or problems with future updates.
The Fix
Prioritize candidates with deep, proven Shopify experience. Look for developers who showcase multiple Shopify projects in their portfolio and can speak knowledgeably about platform-specific features. They should understand Shopify's theme structure, know how to work with metafields, and be familiar with popular apps and integrations.
Ask technical questions specific to Shopify during interviews. How would they optimize site speed? What's their approach to customizing checkout? Their answers will quickly reveal whether they truly know the platform or are just winging it.
Mistake 7: Not Having a Clear Contract or Agreement
The Problem
Starting work without a written contract is like sailing without a compass. When disputes arise about scope, payment, or deadlines, you have no legal protection. Verbal agreements and handshake deals might feel friendly, but they leave both parties vulnerable to misunderstandings and disagreements.
Without clear terms about intellectual property rights, you might not even own the code that was written for your store. This becomes a massive problem if you need to switch developers or make future modifications.
The Fix
Always insist on a detailed written contract before any work begins. This isn't about not trusting people - it's about protecting both parties and ensuring everyone's on the same page. Your contract should clearly outline the project scope, specific deliverables, timeline with milestones, payment schedule, revision policy, and who owns the final code.
Include clauses about what happens if the project goes over timeline or budget. Specify how additional features or changes will be handled and priced. A good developer will appreciate a thorough contract because it protects them too.
Mistake 8: Rushing the Hiring Process
The Problem
Your current store is losing sales, competitors are pulling ahead, and you need changes made yesterday. In this panic, you hire the first available developer without proper vetting. This rushed decision almost always leads to regret.
Desperation clouds judgment. You overlook red flags, skip reference checks, and make compromises you wouldn't normally accept. The developer you hastily hired might not have the skills needed, leading to delays that make your situation even worse.
The Fix
Build buffer time into your project timeline specifically for finding the right developer. Start your search at least 2-3 weeks before you need work to begin. This gives you time to post job listings, review applications, conduct interviews, and check references without feeling pressured.
If you're truly in a time crunch, consider hiring a reputable agency or using a platform with pre-vetted developers rather than rushing through individual freelancer evaluations. It's better to pay a premium for reliability than to waste time and money on a bad hire.
Mistake 9: Disregarding Ongoing Support and Maintenance Needs
The Problem
Many store owners focus entirely on the initial build, forgetting that Shopify stores need regular updates, bug fixes, and improvements. Your developer finishes the project, you pay the final invoice, and then... radio silence. Two months later, when Shopify updates break something or you need a small change, your developer is nowhere to be found or too busy with other projects.
This leaves you scrambling to find someone new who has to learn your store's custom code from scratch, often costing more than the original build.
The Fix
Discuss post-launch support during the hiring process. Ask potential developers about their availability for ongoing maintenance and their rates for future work. Some developers offer monthly retainer packages that guarantee availability for updates and fixes.
Get this agreement in writing as part of your initial contract. Specify response times for different types of issues (critical bugs vs. minor updates) and understand their process for handing off the project if they become unavailable. The best developers will provide documentation and clean code that makes future maintenance easier, whether they do it or someone else does.
Mistake 10: Not Knowing Your Target Audience
The Problem
You hire a developer and tell them to build a "nice looking store" without explaining who your customers are. The developer creates something they think looks good - maybe ultra-modern and minimalist. But your target audience is seniors who need larger fonts and simple navigation. The disconnect between design and audience kills conversions.
A developer who doesn't understand your customers can't make informed decisions about user experience, design elements, or functionality priorities.
The Fix
Before talking to any developer, create a detailed customer persona. Include demographics, shopping behaviors, technical comfort level, and preferences. Share real customer feedback and analytics data if you have it. Explain what your customers value most - is it fast shipping, detailed product information, easy returns, or social proof?
Give your developer context about your industry and competitive landscape. Show them successful competitors and explain what works (and what doesn't) for your specific audience. The more your developer understands your customers, the better they can tailor every aspect of your store to convert visitors into buyers.
Conclusion: Hiring Smarter for Shopify Success
Avoiding these ten common mistakes isn't just about saving money - it's about building a Shopify store that actually grows your business. Each mistake we've covered can derail your project, waste resources, and leave you with a store that underperforms.
The key to successful hiring lies in preparation, patience, and due diligence. Define your requirements clearly, value expertise over cheap rates, thoroughly vet candidates, and always protect yourself with proper contracts. Remember that communication skills matter as much as technical ability, and post-launch support is just as important as the initial build.
Take the time to find a developer who understands not just Shopify, but your specific business needs and target audience. When you avoid these pitfalls and hire the right developer, you're not just getting a service provider - you're gaining a partner in your e-commerce success. Your future self (and your bank account) will thank you for taking the time to hire smart from the start.
References
Like this project
Posted Jun 12, 2025
Hiring a Shopify developer? Steer clear of these 10 common pitfalls, from unclear requirements to neglecting portfolios, to ensure you find the right expert.
Shopify Developer Portfolio: What to Look For & How to Evaluate It Effectively
Shopify Development Projects: From Theme Tweaks to Custom Apps Explained
Successfully Onboarding Your New Shopify Developer: A Checklist for Seamless Integration
Freelance Shopify Developer vs. Agency: Which is Right for Your Business?
