Implement these strategies today and see results by the weekend
You don’t need a complete overhaul or flashy designs to make your emails convert.
The secret? Proven, psychology-backed strategies that work.
These 5 high-impact email campaigns are built on motivating factors that convert your customers.
Tried and trusted by leading CPG brands, we’re breaking down the strategies that deliver real results.
The foundations are strong, so they can be adapted to be used as singular campaigns, or integrated into your core flows.
🎁 Free Gift with Purchase
Why It Works
Offering a free gift is an effective way to grow your email list or re-engage inactive subscribers. This personal gesture encourages immediate action, and with added personalization it can become one of your top performing campaigns.
Best Use Cases
Ideally send as the first email in your Welcome Flow, or as a seasonal campaign to existing subscribers.
Try it as a re-engagement campaign to bring back those who have only purchased once.
Why It Works
Sharing your brand’s story is what builds emotional connection and loyalty. People feel good about supporting brands with authentic, mission-driven stories, especially family-run businesses.
Best Use Cases
Holiday campaigns or brand milestones (e.g., “From Our Family to Yours This Holiday Season”)
Include in your Welcome Flow as a personal touch from the founder or team
Why It Works
A simple shift in language from “free shipping” to “we’ll pay for your shipping” creates a more personal, brand-driven appeal. It becomes a thoughtful gesture rather than a transactional discount.
Best Use Cases
New customer education or product highlights in Post-Purchase or Welcome flows
To reinforce product value in a low-effort, high-impact way.
Why It Works
This format clearly communicates key selling points (KSPs) in a straightforward way, providing customers with specific reasons to make a purchase.
Best Use Cases
Paired with limited-time offers to drive urgency
As the third email in your Abandoned Cart sequence to capture hesitant shoppers
Try it as a product highlight
Why It Works
Induce a sense of urgency in your emails by reminding them of estimated shipping times and the last day to order in time for the holidays or seasonal events.
Best Use Cases
If you do pop-ups or IRL events, invite your customers to join you and offer a discount or merch item if they show you the email
Create a Seasonal Campaigns Flow that sends out reminders for major holidays important shipping dates.
Offer Strategy
Free Gift with purchase has consistently outperformed all other opt-in incentives we’ve tried for our clients. Nothing beats free!
Multi-Step Consent
Get consent early and disable the added subscription confirmation email. Use this as an opportunity to gather zero party data to help with segmentation.
Multi-step pop-ups are some of the highest converting PLUS they help you get around that pesky “Confirm Your Subscription” email, making it easier for you to get in their inbox. You can use the multi-step to collect zero-party data, or collect a phone number for SMS. These are just a few examples we’ve seen recently.
Examples from others in the CPG space
👀 Exclusive Offer! $100 $25 Template Bundle!
Get the templates to implement these strategies today and get some quick wins before the holiday season picks up. We even threw in 7 extra emails that we’ve seen work wonders for our clients, including a 3-day sequence for Black Friday!