Editorial vs. Product-First Shopify Product Page DesignEditorial vs. Product-First Shopify Product Page Design
The network for creativity
Join 1.25M professional creatives like you
Connect with clients, get discovered, and run your business 100% commission-free
Creatives on Contra have earned over $150M and we are just getting started
Two different approaches to the same Shopify product page.
Option A: Editorial layout. Large imagery, generous spacing, and a stronger focus on brand storytelling.
Option B: Product-first layout. Clear pricing, visible product options, and a prominent Add to Cart button.
Both can look great, but they create very different shopping experiences.
If you were building a premium DTC brand, which direction would you choose?
A or B? And why?

1 voted

11%

Option A

8 voted

89%

Option B

9 votes

Closed

Ali's avatar
B for me. premium can come from the photos and type, but if the price and add to cart aren't visible first, a lot of people won't scroll to find them. I'd keep B and put A's story section right under it
Asif's avatar
That's a smart approach! Keeping the buying essentials visible while bringing in A's storytelling below gives customers both clarity and a stronger brand experience. Especially on mobile, that balance can make a big difference.
Ali's avatar
yeah mobile is where it matters most. a sticky add to cart bar once people scroll into the story section helps a lot too
Asif's avatar
Nice choice! B keeps things simple and makes the buying process more straightforward. Sometimes that clarity is exactly what a product page needs.
Vineet's avatar
Going with A for a premium DTC brand, but I would keep the Add to Cart sticky so the storytelling never costs you the cGoing with A for a premium DTC brand, but I would keep the Add to Cart sticky so the storytelling never costs you the conversion path. Option B feels more like...
Asif's avatar
Exactly! A sticky Add to Cart is a great way to balance both. You get the premium storytelling experience without making customers work harder to purchase. That's the sweet spot between strong branding and good UX.
Adil's avatar
For a Shopify product page I would start product first and let the story support it. Shoppers need the options and the buy step in reach before anything else.
Asif's avatar
Exactly. Product-first keeps the buying path clear, and the story can then add the context and emotion that helps close the decision.
Adil's avatar
Exactly, that is the balance I try to keep on client stores too. Clear buying path first, story woven in after.
Vara's avatar
Option B gets my vote. Skincare shoppers want quick facts clear sizes, reviews, ingredients and an obvious "Add to cart" button. Option A looks pretty like a magazine but a tiny text link makes buying harder than it needs to be.
Asif's avatar
That’s a strong point. For skincare, clarity around the product and purchase decision matters more than a purely editorial look. B makes the next step much easier.
ZELYQOR's avatar
I'd go with B and borrow A's photography. A premium product page can still tell a strong brand story, but people shouldn't have to scroll around just to find the price or buy button. I'd keep those essentials visible upfront and let the photography and storytelling do their work further down.
Asif's avatar
Exactly. B gives the buying journey the clarity it needs, while A’s photography can still bring in that premium brand feel without getting in the way of conversion.
Priyadarshani's avatar
Both approaches work really well in their own way! Option A has a beautiful editorial feel that's great for brand storytelling, while B makes exploring the product and purchasing much more straightforward. For a premium DTC product page, I'd lean toward B since it brings...
Asif's avatar
Yeap! That balance is what makes B stronger for me too. It keeps the premium feel, but the shopping path is much clearer and easier to act on.
gargi's avatar
Option A triggers purchase
Back to feed
The network for creativity
Join 1.25M professional creatives like you
Connect with clients, get discovered, and run your business 100% commission-free
Creatives on Contra have earned over $150M and we are just getting started