The network for creativity
Join 1.25M professional creatives like you
Connect with clients, get discovered, and run your business 100% commission-free
Creatives on Contra have earned over $150M and we are just getting started
Back to feedPost
Taste Test
I created two ad creatives for Pureloxa, a skincare brand using two different AI tools to generate the model and visuals. Same product, same brand, same prompt but two completly different output.
This is a real experiment I ran to understand how different AI image generators perform when it comes to commercial advertising, specifically product placement, skin realism, lighting, and how convincingly the model "sells" the product.
Your job is simple, look at both images and vote:
š
° Which visual feels more like a real brand ad?
š
± Which AI did a better job advertising the lotion?
2 voted
40%
3 voted
60%
5 votes
Closed
Chatgpt has a more realistic feel
The network for creativity
Join 1.25M professional creatives like you
Connect with clients, get discovered, and run your business 100% commission-free
Creatives on Contra have earned over $150M and we are just getting started
Related posts
How do you brand a ritual instead of a product?
Trenti is a premium concept store in Buenos Aires. Fire pits, artisan cutlery, curated gifts. Not a restaurant, not a BBQ brand. A store built around one idea: Fuego & Materia. Fire and matter.
So the identity is literal about it. Embers on raw concrete, a restrained serif, a palette pulled from the materials themselves (paper, iron, wood, charcoal) instead of the saturated orange every fire brand defaults to.
The exploration ran across Nano Banana, ChatGPT and Claude for prompt-building. Three engines to generate directions fast. But the final moodboard was curated and composed by hand.
AI made generating moodboard directions free. So where does our value actually live now? Do you let clients see your raw explorations? š
This is massive
Currently running an A/B test with these Facebook ads.
Then I thought... why not ask fellow creatives? š
Just by looking at the designs, which one do you think will get the highest CTR?
Cast your vote before I reveal the results. I'm curious to see whether design intuition matches real user behavior.
5 voted
50%
5 voted
50%
10 votes
Closed
AI model photography for fashion and e-commerce.
One product. Six angles. Multiple locations. Consistent model.
For brands that need to scale content without scaling the studio.
First 5 brands to reach out get a complimentary test shot.
Comment or DM.
Challenges
View all
Trending
Claude
Claude has entered the design space. How are you using Claude Design?
Contra University
Learn from expert creatives how to earn more using next-gen AI tools.
fifaworldcup2026
The World Cup is here and the whole world's watching. How are you designing for the world stage?
creativeaiflow
Creative AI workflows are evolving. What tools do you use, and what are their strengths and weaknesses?
freelancerlife
Freelancer life is wins, pivots, and everything in between. Whatās yours right now?