Diagnostic 001: The Reality-Reporting Drift Audit
Defa Arimasera
Case 001: The Reality-Reporting Drift Audit
An advertising agency with ~100 contractors and a small PM layer was “using ClickUp,” but leadership dashboards didn’t reflect real execution. Work happened asynchronously, task updates were inconsistent, and time tracking was incomplete—so reporting became a polite fiction. Founders couldn’t reliably justify hours, workload, or cost because the system wasn’t being used the same way by everyone.
The Structural Audit
Audit Scope: Full review of ClickUp workspace structure + dashboards, plus the agency’s ad-hoc request channels (chat/messages/email) that fed work into the system.
Behavioral Gap: Identified where teams were bypassing ClickUp to work off-tool (async contractors), leading to missing start dates, inconsistent status changes, and incomplete time logs.
Friction Score: Severe “Chaos Tax” — dashboards could not be trusted because inputs weren’t standardized, so leadership visibility was outdated by default.
“The dashboards weren’t ‘wrong’ because ClickUp was weak. They were wrong because the agency had no shared Decision Protocol—no single intake, no required fields, no minimum behavior standard for statuses and time logs. I designed a lightweight system where the workflow forces clarity (owner + dates + category), and automations enforce accountability. That shifted the agency from memory-based management to system-based visibility.”
The Reality Report & Blueprint
The Diagnostic concluded with a Red Line Prescription designed to protect the agency’s creative margins by aligning execution → data → reporting.
Centralized Project Source of Truth (one intake path + standardized task setup)
Minimum Task Standards (Owner, Start Date, Due Date, Department, Campaign/Priority required)
Decision Protocol for Work Readiness (PM triage: “Ready to start?” yes/no)
Contractor Execution Rules (status behavior + “Blocked” reason when stuck)
Time Tracking Standard (simple, consistent logging so hours/cost can be justified)
Real-time Leadership Visibility Dashboard (workload, overdue, completion, time logged vs estimate)
Automated Alerts to Managers (overdue, overload, stuck statuses, missing time logs)
Like this project
Posted Jan 6, 2026
Conducted a full audit of an agency's ClickUp system to improve reporting accuracy.
