The Algorithm Update Question: Testing Your SEO Expert's Adaptability
Gordon Ibarra
The Algorithm Update Question: Testing Your SEO Expert's Adaptability
Why Algorithm Shifts Affect Your Visibility
What Is SEO Adaptability
Tips for Evaluating Expert Flexibility
1. Knowledge of Algorithm History
2. Proficiency in Technical Audits
3. Focus on E-E-A-T
Techniques to Survive Major Updates
1. Ongoing Content Refresh
2. Strengthening Internal Links
3. Diversifying Content Types
Tracking Success After Each Update
FAQs about Algorithm Changes and Hiring an SEO Expert
Which Google algorithm update focuses on content quality?
How to stay ahead of algorithm changes?
Does updating site design affect SEO results?
Wrapping It All Up
The Algorithm Update Question: Testing Your SEO Expert's Adaptability
Every time Google rolls out a new core update, I get the same message from at least one client: “What just happened to our rankings?” It’s almost like clockwork.
As a freelance SEO strategist, I’ve learned to plan my weeks around these updates. I keep snacks nearby, tabs open, and Slack notifications on high alert. Because when the algorithm shifts, the ripple effect can hit fast—and not always where you expect.
Some updates barely move the needle. Others feel like a complete reshuffling of the web. And while clients look to me for answers, the reality is this: it’s not just about understanding what changed, but how fast you can respond to it.
The question isn’t whether your SEO expert knows how Google works. The real test is how they handle the moment things stop working the way they used to.
Why Algorithm Shifts Affect Your Visibility
Google updates its algorithm thousands of times a year, but only a few of those changes are big enough to affect rankings across industries. When a major update hits, it can cause your site to jump up—or drop out—of the search results, sometimes overnight.
These shifts happen because Google adjusts how it evaluates content. That includes everything from how it interprets search intent to how it weighs trust signals like author credentials or page performance.
Even if your site was optimized last month, a sudden shift in what Google prioritizes can make that previous strategy less effective. What worked yesterday might be ignored today.
Industries experience updates differently. Health, finance, and YMYL (Your Money or Your Life) sites are usually hit harder due to stricter quality standards. Meanwhile, niche blogs or local service pages might barely notice a change.
“It’s like updating the rules of a game mid-match—but only some players get the memo.”
Even within the same industry, the impact can vary depending on how much your site relies on organic traffic, how fresh your content is, or how well your technical SEO holds up under new ranking factors.
Visibility loss doesn’t always mean your content is bad. It might just mean the rules changed—and your site hasn’t caught up yet.
What Is SEO Adaptability
SEO adaptability is the ability to adjust strategies, systems, and content in response to search engine algorithm updates. It applies to both freelancers managing client sites and businesses maintaining internal teams.
Adaptability includes recognizing when rankings drop, identifying what changed, and knowing which actions to take. It also means not relying on fixed playbooks or outdated tactics.
Most algorithm changes don’t come with instructions. Updates like the March 2025 Core Update introduced new quality signals, such as real-time behavior modeling and stricter E-E-A-T requirements. These shifts impact how pages are ranked, even if nothing on the website changed.
Quick action is part of adaptability. Waiting several weeks to respond can lead to lost traffic, missed conversions, and lower visibility. High-performing teams in 2025 adjusted their strategies within 6.2 hours on average after identifying an update.
"Adaptability isn’t about reacting perfectly—it’s about reacting fast enough to stay visible."
The technical side matters too. If Core Web Vitals thresholds are tightened, a slow response from devs can make even well-written pages lose ranking. If new SERP features appear, content teams may need to reformat articles or add schema markup within days, not months. Yoast SEO freelancers can help implement schema updates swiftly.
Adaptability also includes knowing when to stop doing something that once worked. For example, keyword clusters that performed well in 2024 may now be deprecated due to updated semantic models like Neural Matching 4.0.
🧩 In simple terms: adaptability is recognizing change, responding quickly, and knowing what to update—without waiting for a manual that won’t arrive.
Tips for Evaluating Expert Flexibility
1. Knowledge of Algorithm History
An SEO expert’s ability to adapt is directly tied to how well they understand the algorithm's evolution. Google’s updates aren’t random — they follow patterns. Someone who has tracked updates like Panda (2011), Medic (2018), Helpful Content (2022), and the recent March 2025 Core Update is likely better at recognizing what’s changed and what that means for rankings.
Ask which updates they believe had the most impact on their past projects, and what actions they took as a result. If the answer sounds vague or generic, it may suggest they’re reacting passively rather than proactively.
“If they can’t name an update, they probably didn’t notice it — and if they didn’t notice it, they didn’t react to it.”
Most professionals rely on trusted update trackers like Search Engine Journal’s Google Algorithm History or use tools with anomaly detection features. Some use personal systems: spreadsheets tracking keyword shifts before and after updates, or internal wikis that document ranking fluctuations tied to specific algorithm events.
2. Proficiency in Technical Audits
Technical adaptability starts with knowing what to check, and how fast to act. Core Web Vitals—especially Largest Contentful Paint (LCP), First Input Delay (FID), and Cumulative Layout Shift (CLS)—are still part of the ranking equation in 2025. LCP now expects under 1.8s for mobile-first indexing.
Site structure is another area under scrutiny. Flat hierarchies, internal link clarity, crawl depth, and structured data schemas all influence crawl efficiency and content discoverability. If a site has unnecessary JavaScript bloat or fragmented navigation paths, it can lose visibility during updates focused on performance or user intent.
Speed of implementation matters. Some freelancers build modular systems using headless CMS setups or templated code blocks to deploy fixes within hours. If an expert needs “a couple of weeks” to run an audit or implement changes, they may be too slow for real-time updates.
Blockquote:
“The site broke during the update? Cool. Let’s circle back next sprint.” — said no adaptable SEO expert ever.
3. Focus on E-E-A-T
Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, and Trustworthiness (E-E-A-T) are now evaluated through multi-modal signals. In 2025, this includes author credentials, institutional affiliations, and even citation patterns in external publications.
Look for how an expert approaches E-E-A-T in practical terms. Do they suggest adding author bios with verified credentials? Are they using schema to tag medical or legal content with structured professional data? Do they recommend publishing on external platforms to build authority backlinks?
Experts who anchor their strategies in E-E-A-T often prioritize quality over volume. Instead of publishing five derivative blog posts, they’ll spend time creating one deeply researched article with expert quotes, peer-reviewed references, and original visuals.
“Your SEO expert shouldn’t just know what E-E-A-T stands for — they should know what it looks like in your source code.”
Brand consistency matters too. Algorithms now evaluate whether a site’s tone, values, and authorship remain stable across content types and formats. If your homepage promotes trust and your blog posts read like AI-generated filler, that inconsistency affects rankings.
Techniques to Survive Major Updates
1. Ongoing Content Refresh
Content published before 2023 often lacks the semantic depth or structural clarity required after the March 2025 Core Update. Google’s latest systems, like Neural Matching 4.0, analyze contextual alignment more than surface-level keyword density. This makes older content—especially posts relying on outdated phrasing or shallow information—vulnerable to ranking drops.
Refreshing involves more than updating the publish date. It includes rewriting outdated sections, reformatting headers to match intent clusters, and replacing broken or low-authority links. Adding new internal references to recent content also signals that the piece is maintained and connected.
Pages that were optimized around deprecated search behaviors (e.g. voice search phrasing from 2021) often perform worse post-update. Rewriting those to match current query formats—based on live SERP analysis—can restore visibility.
“That blog post from 2020 with five H2s and zero citations? It’s probably invisible now.”
Refreshed content with verified authorship, supporting data, and updated media assets tends to re-index faster and retain traffic through future updates. Freelancers often batch-refresh archive content quarterly, using performance data to prioritize high-traffic or high-bounce URLs. SEO content managers excel at planning and executing these refresh cycles.
2. Strengthening Internal Links
Internal linking is one of the lowest-effort, highest-impact adjustments after algorithm shifts. When rankings drop, redistributing authority from strong-performing pages can stabilize visibility across clusters.
Pages that lost traffic after March 2025 often lacked internal support from related articles or product pages. Linking high-authority evergreen content to newly published or updated pages helps Google understand topical relevance and crawl paths.
Adding contextual anchor text (not generic phrases like “click here”) and linking between pages that satisfy complementary intents—for example, a general service page and a specific use-case guide—improves both discovery and engagement.
“Think of your site as a subway map. If stations (pages) aren’t connected, nobody transfers.”
Freelancers managing multiple clients often maintain internal linking maps using visual tools like GlooMaps or Screaming Frog exports. Screaming Frog SEO Spider freelancers are skilled in leveraging these exports for deeper site audits. These maps highlight orphaned pages and overburdened hubs, making it easier to rebalance link flow quickly after updates.
Guidelines after recent updates also recommend limiting JavaScript-rendered navigation where possible. Static HTML links are more crawl-stable and reduce delay in authority flow, especially on mobile-first crawls.
3. Diversifying Content Types
The March 2025 update emphasized real-time intent modeling, which surfaced more multimedia results—especially short-form video, podcast snippets, and interactive widgets. Static text content alone often fails to meet user expectations for certain queries.
Diversifying formats helps content appear in more SERP features: videos can enter carousels, infographics can trigger visual snippets, and podcasts can rank in audio panels. This widens visibility beyond traditional blue links.
For example, blog posts that previously ranked well for “how-to” queries are now frequently outranked by 60–90-second instructional videos with subtitles, schema markup, and strong engagement metrics.
Adding embedded media also increases on-page engagement. Pages with video or audio segments see longer dwell times and lower bounce rates, which are increasingly tied to intent satisfaction signals.
“Google wants to see if people stick around. Images load fast, but a podcast keeps them there.”
Freelancers frequently repurpose blog content into short videos using tools like Descript or Canva, then embed those on the original page. This allows older content to compete in newer SERP formats without starting from scratch.
Tracking Success After Each Update
After an algorithm update rolls out, rankings alone don’t show the full picture. Metrics like dwell time, user engagement, and conversions provide more precise signals of whether a site is aligned with the new ranking framework. These metrics reflect how users interact with content—whether they stay, click, explore, or leave immediately.
Dwell time refers to how long a user stays on a page after clicking from search results. A drop in dwell time after an update may indicate a mismatch between content and updated intent modeling. Google's March 2025 update introduced session-based evaluations that prioritize experience continuity, meaning that even a 10-second decrease in average time on page can affect visibility.
User engagement includes scroll depth, clicks on internal links, video play rates, and form interactions. These behaviors are now weighted more heavily in micro-moment analysis, which contributes to how Google scores page satisfaction. Engagement drop-offs across multiple pages in a content cluster can indicate that the affected pages no longer match evolving query expectations.
Conversions—whether signups, purchases, downloads, or inquiries—are often the last metric to shift but the most important for evaluating business impact. A site may retain rankings but lose conversions if the update reorders content that previously drove qualified traffic.
“Ranking #1 with zero conversions is like throwing a party no one wants to stay at.”
To respond effectively, a post-update checklist can streamline the review process:
đź—‚ Post-Update SEO Checklist (April 30, 2025 Edition):
Traffic Source Comparison
Filter organic sessions by landing page.
Identify top 10 pages with highest drop in click-through rate.
Dwell Time and Bounce Rate Audit
Compare average session duration pre- and post-update (last 7 days).
Flag any pages with a >15% drop in time on page.
Conversion Funnel Tracking
Analyze form completions, checkout flows, or lead inquiries.
Segment by device type and referrer to isolate friction points.
Content Relevance Review
Re-run affected pages through NLP tools like MarketMuse or Clearscope.
Identify outdated sections or mismatched headings.
SERP Feature Monitoring
Track loss or gain of featured snippets, video carousels, or FAQ panels.
Document changes in visual layout or content type appearing in top 5.
Internal Link Flow Check
Crawl site to detect orphaned or underlinked pages.
Prioritize relinking from high-authority evergreen content.
Schema and Structured Data Validation
Run updated pages through Google's Rich Results Test.
Validate that schema types match revised content format (e.g., FAQ, HowTo, Article).
UX and Mobile Performance
Retest Core Web Vitals, especially Largest Contentful Paint (LCP < 1.8s).
Check for layout shifts or broken interactions on mobile.
E-E-A-T Signal Update
Verify author bios are present and linked to credential sources.
Ensure outbound citations lead to authoritative domains.
Weekly Ranking Snapshot
Log rank changes for top 25 keywords.
Visualize shifts by intent category (navigational, informational, transactional).
This checklist is repeated weekly for 30 days post-update. Patterns typically stabilize by week three. If metrics continue trending downward after week four, content or technical corrections are often escalated.
🧠“If you're only checking rankings, you're missing 90% of the algorithm conversation.”
Consistent documentation of each update’s impact builds a reference archive. Over time, this archive helps identify which areas—content structure, link depth, or technical performance—are most sensitive to change.
FAQs about Algorithm Changes and Hiring an SEO Expert
Which Google algorithm update focuses on content quality?
The earliest major update centered on content quality was Panda, launched in 2011. It targeted thin, duplicate, or low-value content and significantly reduced visibility for sites relying on mass-produced pages with little original information.
In 2018, the Medic update refined this direction by elevating content tied to expertise and trust, especially in health and finance. It introduced stricter quality evaluations for what Google classifies as YMYL (Your Money or Your Life) content.
The Helpful Content Update in 2022 marked a shift toward rewarding content "written by people, for people." It penalized content created primarily to rank on search engines, especially when it failed to meet user expectations.
The March 2025 Core Update added more complex quality evaluation. It incorporated real-time user intent modeling and expanded E-E-A-T scoring using structured author credentials, citation networks, and content maintenance signals. Pages with outdated or unverified content dropped in rankings, even if they previously performed well.
"If your blog post reads like it was written by a bot in 2016, the 2025 algorithm reads it like one too. SEO writers can keep your content human-centric and up-to-date."
How to stay ahead of algorithm changes?
Daily monitoring of search performance and SERP features is the baseline. Most adaptable SEO experts use anomaly detection tools and rank tracking systems that flag early signals—like sudden volatility in long-tail keyword clusters or changes in snippet ownership.
Many follow update trackers such as Search Engine Journal’s Google Algorithm History or rely on platforms that integrate predictive alerts from web crawlers and analytics APIs.
Flexible strategies involve modular content structures, where sections can be rewritten or restructured without full-page redesigns. Some freelancers use headless CMS setups or content blocks that allow faster implementation of changes.
"If they're always surprised by updates, they’re not watching closely enough."
Cross-functional awareness is also involved—SEO experts embedded in product or development teams can respond faster when technical updates (like LCP thresholds tightening to 1.8s) impact rankings.
Does updating site design affect SEO results?
Yes, design changes affect SEO when they alter how users interact with the page or how search engines interpret it. Updates that restructure navigation, change URL paths, or impact mobile responsiveness can shift rankings.
User experience metrics—like scroll behavior, click patterns, and time on page—are now tied to algorithmic models that evaluate intent satisfaction. A design that obscures key content or introduces intrusive elements (like pop-ups) can reduce engagement and lower rankings.
Page speed is another factor. If the redesign increases load time or breaks Core Web Vitals thresholds (especially LCP, CLS, and INP), visibility may decline. This is especially true post-March 2025, where mobile-first indexing evaluates performance in real-time.
“That new hero video might look great, but if it delays LCP by 1.2 seconds, Google sees it as dead weight.”
Search engines also reassess structured data, HTML hierarchy, and accessibility during redesigns. Removing structured elements like FAQ schema or breadcrumb markup can lead to the loss of enhanced search features.
Wrapping It All Up
Adaptability is the defining factor in whether a site maintains visibility or fades out after an algorithm update. As of April 30, 2025, the March core update has made this even clearer. Sites that adapted within the first 6–12 hours saw significantly less traffic loss, while those that waited over a week experienced up to 42% visibility decline.
Stable growth depends on how quickly SEO adjustments are made when algorithm signals shift. That includes checking Core Web Vitals after performance changes, rewriting content to match updated semantic models, and reevaluating E-E-A-T signals when rankings begin to slip.
Algorithm updates now adjust rankings based on real-time user behavior, not just static content. If the SEO expert doesn’t respond to those changes within a short window, the site falls behind. This doesn't require overhauls—just precise, timely actions based on live data.
The role of an SEO partner is no longer limited to audits or content edits. SEO freelancers excel at interpreting algorithm behavior, aligning changes with business goals, and executing updates without delay. freelance SEO specialists who work independently often outperform larger agencies in this area because they can act faster, with fewer layers of approval.
When that freelancer uses a commission-free platform like Contra, they also retain full control of their workflow and pricing, which reinforces accountability. There's no third-party interference. The work is direct, the communication is clear, and the feedback loop is faster.
🧠“The algorithm doesn’t wait for your next sprint planning session.”
Working with someone who understands this—and has the operational freedom to respond immediately—makes a measurable difference.
Like this project
Posted Apr 30, 2025
The Algorithm Update Question tests your SEO expert's adaptability. Learn how fast, flexible strategies help maintain rankings after major Google updates.
SEO Specialists for Hire: The Interview Framework That Reveals All
Find SEO Experts With Provable Results: Documentation to Request
15 Must-Ask Questions When You Hire an SEO Expert
The SEO Audit Challenge: Testing Your Potential Hire's Abilities
