Sin Nadie Que Te Consuele

An editorial / mixed reality project that, through the narration of 11 real cases, seeks to expose several crimes committed by the Venezuelan government in the protests that occurred in 2014 and 2017.

In September 2022, a report presented at United Nations Human Rights Council concluded that “since at least 2014, the Venezuelan Government and its security forces have planned and executed serious human rights violations, constituting, in some cases, crimes against humanity.”

This project is a visual and interactive re-edition of that report aiming to broaden its reach and as a way to remember the victims.

On a personal level, this projects comes as my graduating project in spain, having left venezuela (my home) four years earlier after the 2017’s social/political turmoil.

It is born out of the helplesness and frustration, out of the guilt of having left and out ofd a sense of responsability to hold people accountable.

The main goal of the project was to be able to answer “What’s going in Venezuela?”, especially between 2014 and 2019, in the most visual and efficient way.

Nobody is gonna read a +400 page report, but that was the first (and so far, only) piece of “evidence” set in the ICC that can bring justice to the victims, so it was important for me to get the word out.

The full translated title of the project is “Without Anyone to Comfort You: A Visual Reconstruction of 11 Cases of Crimes against Humanity During the 2014-2017 Protests in Venezuela”.

The “without anyone to comfort you” phrase comes from and old venezuelan salsa song. it’s chorus says “For your bad behavior / You will regret it / And you will have to pay for all my suffering / You will cry and cry / With no one to comfort you/ So that you’ll realize that if you’re cheated, it hurts”

That’s the song a national guard sang to a woman that came to a detention site looking for her 13-year-old daughter.

The mission’s reports that during that time, the girl was being illegaly detained and sexually abused by security forces just for being near a protest.

That’s the level of systemic and political cruelty venezuelas were/are subjected to, while also refelcting on the solitude, despair, abandonment and helplessness felt by many venezuelans during those years.

The UN’s investigation comes after years of begs for help from inside venezuela. In a hard state-wide censorship across media, journalists and photographers played a key role in recording evidence used in these and many other investigations.

So to better illustrate the events that unfolded I reached out to many photo journalists, reporters and even amateur photographers that captured venezuela around those years.

Some of them were kind enough to let me use their pictures for this project:

Iñaki Zugasti‍

Félix Espinoza

I remember the general dispair and dismay felt accross venezuela during those years. Once out of it, i kept getting frustrated because nobody seemed to know what was going on inside venezuela or frankly, even cared.

The need to try and convey those feelings to the outside world became the cornerstones for the project.

The cover photo was taken by photographer Carlos Ramos in the midst of the 2017 protests. The child’s eyes are asking for help.

He’s deep into the combat zone, fighting for something that started long before he was born, yet he feels the need to fight for it.

Many of the victims of the investigation, even the ones that are not featured on this project, range from 13 to 30-years old. That youthness mixed with fear of losing hope was a more-than-common look out in the streets.

There’s also the striking similitude to the “eyes of Chávez”: a pseudo pop-art icon made after his death to be put on high billboards and on top of buildings to “watch over his legacy”.

Essentially the same frame, yet two very different messages connected to each other.

Were not be for chavez, his policies and the subsequent maduro’s government, that kid would have been playing somewhere instead of having to cover himself in antiacid to reduce the gas’ effects on him.

The back cover features the names, dates and locations of 11 of the cases investigated, as well as the names of the photographers and journalists that lent me their material for this project.

There’s also a hand-drawn seven-star arc in the middle, a nod to venezuelan flag pre-2008 that became an icon for the opposition.

In the 2014 and 2017 protests, it was painted into the DIY shields the protestors were using to protect themselves from the security forces

The UN's Fact Finding Mission text forms the backbone of this whole project.

However, their report delves into a spectrum of various crimes spanning different timelines within Venezuela, from 2014 to 2019.

For length and concept reasons, this project only features the investigations for crimes commited during the protests in 2014 and 2017, as well the necessary context.

For that, the project was divided into five sections.

This is all about the mission and their work: who are they, why were they summoned, what are they trying to find out and how.

It explains the political and legal significance of this report inside and outside venezuela, including the realm of the international criminal court.

It’s really hard to answer that witout having to go into a 45 minute speech, but here’s a chronological breakdown of key social and political events that led to the protests where the alleged crimes agains humanity were commited by the government.

It also dissects the roles of state agencies and security forces, which inevitably played a part in the crimes investigated, to establish a clear chain of command and attribute individual accountability.

A maximized view of the 2014 and 2017 protests to grasp their scale and significance, as well as to establish the violent patterns held by government and security forces across both movements.

The Mission pieced together each case through victim and family interviews, examination of legal documents, and the reconstruction of events using social media and media footage.

In all of them, the mission reckons that at least one of this crimes were commited and executed by state or security forces:

Forced disappearances

Arbitrary detentions

Extrajudicial executionsd

Torture, cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment

To make it more accessible, I've reordered the text so it reads chronologically and added animations, maps, diagrams, illustrations, and images where needed.

Each one of the 11 cases is told via the same narrative and overall visual structure:

A cover page with the case’s title, location and dates.

A timeline of national or local events related to the protests during that or previous days.

A timeline of the events that led up to the actual crime.

A page dedicated to each of the case’s victim(s). including their name, age and occupation.

The D.A’s investigation and the judicial processes that followed.

The Mission's conclusions regarding each case.

So it could be easier to follow along, I included different forms of media to this narrations, including:

Satellite images of key places

Social media posts from the victims or goverment officials

Headlines and articles from local or international media outlets

Images from photojournalists

Illustrations of weapons or torture systems

Animations in augmented reality of the events.

In some cases, The investigations are so detailed, that i was able to recreate some of the events using augmented reality and 3d animation.

In these cases the animations make it clear that the official version of the events does not match the evidence found by the council.

There are seven target images spread across some of the cases. when scanned with an app, a 3d animation is kickstarted on top of the page.

Presented as the mission’s findings, here’s where personal and institutional responsability is laid down.

The mission concludes on the physical and intellectual culprits of torture, unlawful detentions, disappearances, and executions as well as asserting violent patterns executed as state policies.

More projects here.