Linguistic Divergence Employed as Resistance
It is acceptable and sometimes expected for a speaker to accommodate to the speech of an
addressee, to ensure that the conversation flows easily, or to let the
addressee know they are regarded with a positive attitude. Linguistic
divergence is a more conscious effort to emphasize the differences between speakers
in an interaction, for some it is a decision to not modify or adjust features
of their speech to that of their addressee. Although, this could be influenced
by the attitudes which speakers have towards other languages, whether they are
dominant or minority languages, it is a speech act which is meant to deliver a
symbolic meaning through its continual use. Language policies which
disadvantage minority language speakers could be a cause of linguistic
divergence, an attempt to keep a language in use and to oppose any restrictions
to its maintenance and innovation. Linguistically divergent behavior is also a
way to represent culture or nationality, in response to shifts towards the
dominant group’s language, “minority ethnic groups who want to maintain and
display their cultural distinctiveness will often, use their own linguistic
variety” (Holmes and Wilson 263). Linguistic divergence counters the societal
expectation that a minority language speaker should converge towards the
dominant language and change their linguistic features to match those of
another group.
In Belarus, a group of speakers use linguistic divergence to express their disapproval of new
language policies which are threatening to displace the Belarusian language indirectly.
These speakers are re-establishing the unofficial Belarusian variety of taraŝkevica,
which was reformed in 1933 towards the officially recognized Belarusian variety
of narkamawka. Speakers of taraŝkevica claim that the narkamawka variety was a
reform inspired not by linguistic concerns that would allow the modified
variety “to simplify the standard orthography,” but as a method to change the
language norms in Belarus to align with those of the dominant group. Speakers
of taraŝkevica are critical of the close relation which the standard Belarusian
linguistic forms share with the standard Russian language, they fear it will
enable the eventual shift towards Russian in most domains, “the post-1933
grammatical and lexical norms associated with it are little more than a Trojan
horse for Russian influence, a means to undermine the Belarusian language from
within” (Woolhiser 376). The neglect of a minority groups’ preferred variety is
what has inspired oppositional language groups, which use taraŝkevica in
independent media as a way to show pride in their Belarusian nationality, this
is what can be interpreted as a “collective form of action denouncing the
tyranny of the majority: the official identity of the ideal citizen” (Dubreuil qtd.
in Kulyk 1031). Where minority groups are faced with politicized actions to diminish
the status of their language, their use of linguistic divergence from the
standard or more prestigious variety is a response to counter this.
At times adherents of a language group are told that their variety is not suitable for formal interactions, such as in government and education, and this can evoke a more pronounced use of code-switching or bilingualism in which the speakers do not conform to the
norms completely, but are found in the need to follow the set expectation. In Brunei
where the use of Malay or first language is discouraged in the educational
classrooms after the “Upper Primary” level, it is found that students often disapprove
of the strict conditions which place English as the only and most important
language intended to be used in this space, “this leads [students] to challenge
the “policing English” policy…which they see as marginalizing their
home/community and national language” (Saxena 176). Malay as the national
language is highly valued in Brunei, supported by the Melayu Islam Beraja ideology
institutionalized throughout Brunei after its independence, it promotes Malay as
an important symbol of “cultural and traditional identity” (Saxena 176). Despite
the linguistic prestige of Malay, English is still considered “the global
language” and is upheld as the sole medium for education, it invalidates the students’
first languages and creates opposition from them. In the Ukraine this issue
also exists between Ukrainian and Russian, the movement of Ukrainianization in
media being a political action which Ukrainian speakers advocated for, they are
disconcerted by the growing force of Russian in most domains, “there have been
dramatic tensions between the two languages on the sociopolitical plane,
raising questions about their respective status and especially their de facto
social, cultural and political functions” (Nedashkivska 353). The prospect of
Russian being given official status alongside the national language in Ukraine,
makes Ukrainian speakers worry their own language will lose its significance as
more people switch to Russian for extensive functions. This is a problem that
tends to arise when the dominant group builds the influence of a language on
the neglect of another, this is a criticism which Ukrainian government and President
Kuchma received because of their ambiguous policies which “orchestrated the
promotion of Ukrainian in education and business, but did not create, nor
promote, any channels for Ukrainian in book publishing and the media”
(Nedashkivska 353). Ukrainian speakers are aware of the impact which Russian
media has on people, it constructs the language use of Russian as the norm and belittles
the role of Ukrainian, this is concerning since “Institutional support
generally makes the difference between success and failure in maintaining a
minority group language” (Holmes and Wilson 68). In nations where language is
part of the ideological contestation of political groups, government support or
dismissal of a minority group’s language is crucial in shaping the dominant
language use. In the Ukraine during and after the Euromaidan Revolution, language
use of Russian and Ukrainian was viewed in relation to the socio-political
context, it made it difficult for the government to adopt new policies which could
appease “the active minority’s call for a radical break with the legacy of the
Russian/Soviet rule and the majority’s preference for the preservation of the
accustomed environment” (Kulyk 1030). During such a critical time in which Euromaidan
supporters wanted to sever their ties to Russia’s influence in the Ukraine,
Russian was considered a remaining impression of its imperialism. This ideology
was inspired by a need to separate Ukrainian as a symbol of nationality, from
Russian which was linked in the minds of many as part of the “Soviet legacy”
(Kulyk 1035). Policies such as the “bilingual media campaign” were considered
half-measures which did not allow the goal of “resolute promotion of Ukrainian”
to occur, escalating the conflict between speakers of both languages (Kulyk
1038).
Linguistic divergence can increase the number of speakers who identify with the divergent
variety, and this attempt at language maintenance can change the linguistic
landscape of a nation and create innovations through the language use of oppositional
language groups. In Belarus, oppositional language groups who advocate for the
restoration of the taraŝkevica variety are the vehicles by which taraŝkevica linguistic
forms are entering the speech of dominant language groups. In a survey of the
language use in Belarus, there were official standard narkamawka variants and unofficial
taraŝkevica variants placed in the questionnaire, and despite what was expected,
Belarusian students who are not engaged in the oppositional language groups
recognized and claimed to use nonofficial variants, such as даляр for dollar
and the adjectival form моладзевы for youth, “independent Belarusian-language
media and groups such as Malady Front and ZBS [are] beginning to influence the
language choices even of those who do not openly identify with the opposition”
(Woolhiser 387). Although these oppositional language groups which refuse to
conform to the dominant language in Belarus regard the taraŝkevica variety as a
legitimate variety, speakers on the outside of these groups not only look down
on this variety but do not consider some of the linguistic forms to be correct
ways of speaking. The use of the pre-1933 taraŝkevica loan words in the Belarusian
standard variety have marked variants which show their linguistic closeness to
Russian or their distance from the older linguistic forms. In a survey conducted
by Curt Woolhiser, it was found that the most linguistically conservative
student who only uses the Belarusian standard variety when needed in school,
rejected Belarusian standard superlative forms such as найтаннейшы and самы
танны even though they are part of the codified variety, they claimed to use
variants which were “closer to Russian models, e.g., ён лепшы студэнт у групе
‘he is the best student in the group’, and ён самы лепшы студэнт (analogous to
the Russian он лучший [самый лучший] студент)” (Woolhiser 393). This shows the
infiltration of the Russian language forms which oppositional groups are
against, the growing similarities between Russian and standard Belarusian makes
them adopt more linguistically distant forms from either. The phonology of the
standard and non-official Belarusian word forms is also an area where
differentiation is practiced, the word for club in the standard Belarusian
variety of narkamawka being клуб and having a nonpalatalized /l/, and the taraŝkevica
variety being клюб and having a palatalized /l’/ (Woolhiser 393). A moderate
speaker with ambivalent feelings towards both official and non-official
varieties, said they used both the клуб and клюб word variants. The taraŝkevica
speaker claimed the nonpalatalized /l/ word form was not appropriate and that
he only used the taraŝkevica pronunciation, and this can be a
confirmation of “the role the innovative variants play in the affirmation of
group membership and status within the group” (Woolhiser 394). The innovative
forms of taraŝkevica are not “forgotten historical variants” like President
Lukashenka claims, but are significantly used by oppositional groups “as a
natural response to dominant discourses that represent linguistic similarity as
a justification for linguistic, cultural, and ultimately political hegemony”
(Woolhiser 376). In Bruneian classrooms the English-only rule which teachers
strictly exercise make it difficult for students to grasp certain concepts as
they are not allowed an explanation in Malay or first language even when
struggling with an English word, in this way the deviation from the English
standard to that of Malay used by some teachers helps students learn and
understand concepts more clearly and efficiently. Through the code-switching of
the teacher and students, there can be a more cooperative learning interaction
between them, an example of this is when a teacher drew on Malay vocabulary to
explain the concept of roaming animals to students that were not as proficient
in English, “...mcm kalau telipun..... {it’s like if a phone} it would, you
know, roaming, right” (Saxena 178).
She code-switches between English and Malay to talk about a subject, because she
knows it will assist the students in their understanding of the passage, she
uses Malay to give them an idea and example of roaming in Malay and the
students draw on this example to make sure they understand what the English
word roam means, a student then asks through code-switching about the meaning, “Roaming” kah ^ {Do you mean “roaming”^}”, and yet another student attempts to elaborate
on the question using only Malay, “Cari makan bah ‘cher... {They’re simply
looking for food...}” (Saxena 178). This interaction goes against the English
norms which Brunei has implemented in the school systems, yet the use of first
language in code-switching is crucial for the development of the language, “For
many bilinguals, certain kinds of referential content are more appropriately or
more easily expressed in one language than the other” (Holmes and Wilson 38).
This is the case in the above example, where students are being taught concepts
in English which they are not yet familiar with, and this creates a gap in
their educational learning, yet “the use of L1 at a strategic juncture in the
discourse serves as retroactive contextualization” (Saxena 178). Linguistic
divergence from the standard or norm is used in this sense to build on shared
knowledge towards the goal of acquiring another language.
In the nations where the identities associated with a certain language are diminished in
value, using media or governmental policies, speakers of those varieties are at
times reluctant to follow this negation of their language. Linguistic divergence
through code-switching or the use of a less accepted variety are resources by
which minority groups maintain and revive a language. Independent media can
help this cause when diverging from the standard variety to that which is
preferred by these groups, it can create a space where other varieties are
legitimized and treated like a more accepted variety. Disapproval of a language
because of the political ideologies associated with it, are also a part of
linguistic divergence, with speakers attempting to place boundaries between the
more dominant variety and its influence. Refusing to engage in the language
which does not represent the ideas and values of a speaker’s group is of
importance in the creation of their identity.
Works Cited
Group 6 in Class 6C of the English
Education Department of Islamic State University of Bandung. “Accommodation
Theory (Convergence and Divergence).” Youtube, 28 Apr. 2018, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=koH6RfjpgJg.
Holmes, Janet and Nick Wilson. “An Introduction to
Sociolinguistics.” edited by Mick Short, Brian Walker, Willem Hollmann,
Geoffrey Leech, ed. 5, Routledge, 2017.
Nedashkivska, Alla. “Symbolic
Bilingualism in Contemporary Ukrainian Media.” Canadian Slavonic Papers, vol.
52, no. 3/4, 2010, pp. 351-372.
Saxena, Mukul. “Construction &
Deconstruction of Linguistic Otherness: Conflict and Cooperative Code-Switching
in (English/) Bilingual Classrooms.” English Teaching, vol. 8, no. 2,
2009, pp. 167-187.
Volodymyr, Kulyk. “Memory and
Language: Different Dynamics in the Two Aspects of Identity Politics in
Post-Euromaidan Ukraine.” Nationalities Papers, vol. 47, no. 6, 2019,
pp. 1030-1047.
Woolhiser, Curt. “Communities of
Practice and Linguistic Divergence: Belarusophone Students as Agents of
Linguistic Change.” Harvard Ukrainian Studies, vol. 29, no. 1-4, 2007,
pp. 371-404.
0 likes · 47 views · Jul 30, 2023
Studied how linguistic divergence is employed across various situations, trying to identify the reason for its use.