Comparing Two Hero Design Directions for a New ProjectComparing Two Hero Design Directions for a New Project
The network for creativity
Join 1.25M professional creatives like you
Connect with clients, get discovered, and run your business 100% commission-free
Creatives on Contra have earned over $150M and we are just getting started
Exploring two different hero directions for a new project. Same message, two completely different visual approaches. Which one makes a stronger first impression?
A or B? Curious to hear your thoughts!

36 voted

90%

Option 1

4 voted

10%

Option 2

40 votes

Closed

Sohil's avatar
Option1 wins
Shakil's avatar
nice work
Edd 's avatar
Thanks a lot!
Alaa 's avatar
Option 1 makes a very strong first impression! The dark background and bold typography give it a powerful and professional leadership feel
Edd 's avatar
Thanks, Alaa! That’s exactly the feel I was going for. Glad it comes through!
Taimur's avatar
Both are strong. I lean towards the dark version, because the orange accent on the italic "guess." pops and the profile portrait gives it a more editorial, confident feel. The navy one reads a bit more corporate, which could suit a more conservative audience. Nice exploration!
Edd 's avatar
Thanks, Taimur! You’ve captured the difference really well. I’m leaning towards the editorial feel of the dark version too!
Rafee's avatar
Option 1 for me. The dark version with the orange on guess gives the headline more weight for a leadership audience.
Vineet's avatar
I would lean toward whichever has the clearer headline hierarchy. A strong first impression is mostly about how fast someone understands the offer, and the visual style can support that after.
Maryam's avatar
Showing the same message in two visual directions is a smart way to get useful feedback. I would also read each hero headline aloud, since a hero that is easy to scan in one breath usually converts better than a clever one. Which headline do you feel is stronger on its own?
Madob 's avatar
Incredible!
Edd 's avatar
Thank you!
Nilkanth's avatar
Option 2 for me. The navy feels more trustworthy for a leadership audience, and the card on the right gives people a reason to keep reading. Option 1 is bolder but has less to hold onto.
Salah's avatar
Well done.
Edd 's avatar
Thanks!
Patrick's avatar
Looks great, nice work
BuiltByKern's avatar
option 1 for me, the orange on the italic "guess" carries the whole line. curious if the navy one lands better with the leaders you're aiming at though
Edd 's avatar
Thanks! Good point about the audience. Option 1 has more character, but I can see the navy direction appealing to more traditional firms.
Hesty 's avatar
Am leaning toward Option 1. The darker, more restrained layout makes the headline stand out and gives the message a stronger sense of authority.
Muhammad Hammad's avatar
option 1 as it easily grabs the attention of a user
Maty's avatar
First of all I think both are really good, but here are my thoughts and why I'm not voting. On layout and text I do prefer dark version. It feels strong and gives a "Leadership" vibe. On the image side, I like that the person is looking at the text, guiding users to it, but...
Edd 's avatar
Thanks for the thoughtful feedback! I see your point about the pose. Definitely something to explore further.
Rishabh's avatar
option 1 is good layout
Mark's avatar
For me 1 even more intriguing
Tabish's avatar
Cool exercise. Funny how the same message lands so differently depending on the visuals. Leaning towards Option 1 for the first impression.
Back to feed
The network for creativity
Join 1.25M professional creatives like you
Connect with clients, get discovered, and run your business 100% commission-free
Creatives on Contra have earned over $150M and we are just getting started