Client’s choice vs. Designer’s choice 👀 I’m currently working on a branding project for Massage ...Client’s choice vs. Designer’s choice 👀 I’m currently working on a branding project for Massage ...
The network for creativity
Join 1.25M professional creatives like you
Connect with clients, get discovered, and run your business 100% commission-free
Creatives on Contra have earned over $150M and we are just getting started
I’m currently working on a branding project for Massage & Mocktails — a concept built around couples learning massage together in a relaxed, social atmosphere.
These are two early, black & white directions from Stage 2 of my branding process, before moving into color, typography, and the full visual system.
The interesting part?
My client chose Concept 1. I chose Concept 2.
Now I’m curious what other creatives think.
Which direction would you choose — 1 or 2? And why?
Sometimes the most interesting part of branding is seeing how differently a client and a designer respond to the same brief.
Concept 2 has the stronger designer-led distinction for me—the contrast gives the identity more personality, while Concept 1 feels like the safer client-facing route. I’d be curious to see how each behaves once typography and color are introduced.
I have to side with the designer's choice on this one. The continuous line art approach is sophisticated and gives the brand a much more premium, distinct identity.
The black and white stage is where the real decisions happen. Both directions read strong before color gets involved. Curious which logo form you ended up taking into final production.
I think the client is thinking more from a business and instant-recognition perspective. The designer’s choice is absolutely nice, but the client’s choice builds easier brand recognition.
Your client went with the mark that reads instantly at badge size, which is usually what wins in the room - the figure mark asks for a second of attention it won't always get on a tote or a sidewalk sign. But that second is where the warmth of the concept actually lives, so I'd...
The biggest misconception about branding is thinking it's just a logo. What actually saves founders time and money later is a compact system a focused 2–3 color palette and clear sub-brand rules so every new deck, social post, or product launch looks cohesive without starting from scratch.
Most gyms follow a pretty similar approach to branding. I wanted to see what a strength club could look like if it drew more inspiration from a private-membership club vibe, since that's really trending right now.
Designed two directions for Arkos using the same mark. A is more refined and traditional, while B takes a bolder, more modern approach.
Should a personal brand hero lead with the name or the promise?
A client of ours is a speaking coach. People find her by name: podcasts, stages, word of mouth. Yet her first hero hid that name in the top-left corner.
We tested two directions:
The promise first. "Speak with confidence" in big type, the name small in the nav. Clear, but it could be any coach on the internet.
The name first. Her name at billboard scale, the promise in one line above it, her face right behind. Someone arriving from a podcast knows instantly they're in the right place.
When people search for you, your name is the headline.