Another client sent us an AI-built page asking if we can "spruce it up." HoldAnother client sent us an AI-built page asking if we can "spruce it up." Hold
The network for creativity
Join 1.25M professional creatives like you
Connect with clients, get discovered, and run your business 100% commission-free
Creatives on Contra have earned over $150M and we are just getting started
Another client sent us an AI-built page asking if we can "spruce it up." Hold our beer. 🍺
Designer vs. AI, who takes it?
Also, comment if you've been gifted one of these beautifully bland masterpieces produced by Claude to spruce up.

9 voted

14%

AI

56 voted

86%

Designer

65 votes

Closed

Sharon's avatar
AI is the best
Sahil's avatar
Impressive design !
Nikita's avatar
YoungYosha logo
Great work, guys. Definitely made by a designer!
Nikita's avatar
YoungYosha logo
the left one =)
Oluwadamilola's avatar
Who even voted AI 😭
Regent Park Studio logo
😂 😂 😂 (not us!)
Kehinde's avatar
AI can do it as well; it depends on the prompt you use in generating it
Victor's avatar
Designer!!!
Regent Park Studio logo
You know it!
Boluwatife's avatar
Noth beats human designers.... Great work as usual @Regent Park Studio
Oscar Daniel's avatar
By looking at it, I'm not yet sure which is which... Because AI doesn't use the same template EVERY. SINGLE. TIME. 🤣 Very well done and very nice design!
Regent Park Studio logo
Plot twist: we're actually AI.
Guoshuai's avatar
This is clean, confident, and well executed.
Koonj's avatar
Designer
Esther 's avatar
Designer
Gideon's avatar
The designer version is definitely better.
Koushik's avatar
Nice design
BuiltByLiyah's avatar
Designer
Louis's avatar
The designer is looking more appealing
Bhaskar's avatar
Designer wins for me.
The AI version gets the structure right, but every element carries the same visual weight, so nothing really stands out.
The designer version introduces hierarchy through spacing, contrast, and grouping. My eye immediately knows where to look first, which...
ZOHAIB's avatar
AI is not face the Human Power
Chidera 's avatar
I love the Designer better. Visuals and illustrations always know how to communicate better
Atolani's avatar
Designer looks more better!
Victor's avatar
Vprime Digitalz logo
Designer is lit 🔥
Brandon's avatar
The AI one isn't bad at all, but you definitely gave it more a distinct brand feel and personality. Choosing yours over it for sure.
Adesuyi's avatar
"AI can generate a starting point, but it rarely solves the real UX problems. The biggest value designers bring is turning something functional into something users actually enjoy using."
hira's avatar
AI DESIGN IS BEST
Back to feed
The network for creativity
Join 1.25M professional creatives like you
Connect with clients, get discovered, and run your business 100% commission-free
Creatives on Contra have earned over $150M and we are just getting started