When an Ad Looks AI-Generated, Does It Lose the Click?
AI can now produce remarkably polished advertising images. But could that polished appearance sometimes work against the advertisement?
A study recently published in Marketing Science examined 4,633 comparable display ads on Taboola, representing more than 369 million impressions.
On average, ads using AI-generated images showed no detectable click-through disadvantage compared with those using human-made images.
The more interesting finding was about perception.
In a separate evaluation, participants often misidentified which images were AI-generated. And ads whose images appeared more artificial tended to receive fewer clicks, regardless of how the images had been produced.
Highly aesthetic images and intense color saturation were among the visual cues participants associated with AI.
What interests me is the gap between how we evaluate creative work and how an audience might perceive it.
A marketing team may approve an image because it looks technically impressive. But that doesn't tell us whether the same visual qualities will resonate with its customers.
The research doesn't establish that natural-looking images always perform better, and clicks aren't sales.
It does suggest that perceived artificiality is worth examining alongside other measures of advertising effectiveness.
Could the qualities that make an AI image look impressive also make an advertisement less appealing?