Conversion Rate Optimization Recommendations for a Pet Supplement PageConversion Rate Optimization Recommendations for a Pet Supplement Page
The network for creativity
Join 1.25M professional creatives like you
Connect with clients, get discovered, and run your business 100% commission-free
Creatives on Contra have earned over $150M and we are just getting started
I saw a Dog is Human ad in my Facebook feed.
"Itchy dog?"
So I clicked.
And I landed on a page that opens with "DM-01™ Daily Multivitamin."
The ad sold itch relief. The page sold a multivitamin.
So I started digging.
According to traffic tools (estimates, not their real numbers):
1.22M visits a month
$3M–$6M estimated monthly revenue
477 active Meta ads
6,000+ ads pointing to one product page
That's a lot of paid clicks landing on pages that don't match the ad.
At that scale, even small leaks cost real money.
So I couldn't stop myself.
Here are the 9 changes I'd make if I were their CRO:
One offer in the announcement bar. Not 3 rotating messages nobody reads.
Press logos on image #1. "As seen in The Dodo" before they scroll.
The Itch-Free Guarantee, twice. On the image and right under the CTA.
Name it for the problem. "Itch & Skin Daily Multivitamin" + "For dogs who scratch, lick their paws or get hot spots."
Lead with the best proof. "97% saw less itching in 3–6 months." It was hidden on gallery image #4.
One price line. $36.98, $58 crossed out, save 36%. No math.
A subscription card that says what you get. 15% off, 25% off today, free shipping, easy cancel.
A CTA you can actually read. White on pale blue was ~1.9:1 contrast. Navy, with the price inside.
Guarantee + shipping right under the button. That's where the doubt shows up.
I wouldn't ship all 9 at once.
I'd A/B test them in order, starting with the headline and the button, and judge each one on revenue per visitor.
From what I've seen on pages like this, I'd expect a real lift. But the test decides, not me.
The ad says itch. The page should say itch.
Want to see what I'd test on yours?
Comment your brand, and I'll show you exactly what I'd change if I were your CRO.
#conversionrateoptimization
Post image
Rasaq's avatar
Ad-to-page mismatch is a silent leak. Smart teardown, #1 and #8 stand out. 🔥
AL's avatar
agree
Rasaq's avatar
Glad it resonates! 🙌
Back to feed
The network for creativity
Join 1.25M professional creatives like you
Connect with clients, get discovered, and run your business 100% commission-free
Creatives on Contra have earned over $150M and we are just getting started