The network for creativity
Join 1.25M professional creatives like you
Connect with clients, get discovered, and run your business 100% commission-free
Creatives on Contra have earned over $150M and we are just getting started
Back to feedPost
Freelance writers: keep the reason behind a declined suggestion in the feedback record.
In the Content Production and Approval Kit's fictional coffee-launch example, three comments reach a decision:
• Clarify pause timing: accepted; Nora specifies five days before dispatch in v1.2
• Add a health-benefit claim: declined by Ellis because the approved fact sheet doesn't support it
• Make the plan link clearer: accepted; Nora adds descriptive link text in v1.2
The next draft contains two changes. The review record accounts for all three comments.
For your next revision round, give each comment a decision, a responsible person and a resolution reference. Keep the reason for a declined suggestion beside the original comment so the next reviewer can see why that wording was left out. If a request still needs clarification, record who will answer, by when and which work depends on it.
Return the revised draft with a short summary of the edits and the suggestions deliberately excluded. That gives the approver a clear record of what happened to the feedback.
Shown: actual page 5 of the kit's fictional completed example. All people, decisions and records are invented for teaching. The download includes a seven-page editable Word packet, an Excel tracker with 40 asset rows, printable PDFs, the completed example and a Quick Start. Designed for desktop Word and Excel; review decisions and checks are manual.
The network for creativity
Join 1.25M professional creatives like you
Connect with clients, get discovered, and run your business 100% commission-free
Creatives on Contra have earned over $150M and we are just getting started
Related posts
Congrats to the winners, the craft on those projects is impressive.
I’d like to add a constructive note on transparency. The brief listed four criteria: problem-solving impact, owner-effort reduction, craft and storytelling. My entry (Suds & Scissors, a booking system for a solo mobile dog groomer in Portland) focused on the first two: an AI texting assistant that turns “can you fit my doodle in?” into a booked, deposit-backed slot, plus automated reminders, waitlist refills and no-show protection.
I’m not questioning anyone’s effort or the winners’ quality. It would just help everyone improve if Contra shared a short note on how the criteria were weighted, and maybe brief feedback for finalists. That would make future challenges feel worth the investment for newer members too.
Totally agree with you Biswas! Transparency really matters in these challenges. Your Suds & Scissors booking system sounds super practical with strong problem-solving impact. Would love to see your entry! Craft is important but real-world utility should count more. 👏
The freelancer starter pack for Contra that nobody gives you.
📚 Cuared portfolio with similar work than the clients that you want to get.
⏳ Save a couple minutes or hours a day to engage with the community and apply to Contra Jobs.
📄 Contract (protect yourself before you need to)
📊 Presentation template to stop rebuilding every one from scratch.
💸 Price list (custom quotes, yes. Starting from zero every time, no.)
📋 Client onboarding questionnaire (get the info before the chaos)
✉️ A few email templates for proposals, feedback reminders, and awkward payment conversations.
What would you add to the starter pack?
Great list. I'd add a simple handoff guide for the client, so they can keep the site updated after launch without coming back for every small change.
my second entry friends😍
I’d be happy to hear your thoughts and feedback.
Thank you.
Spotlight – Please Touch | Tap-to-Play Product Launch Template
Spotlight – Please Touch is a tap-to-play SVGator template for product drops, launches and social promos, made for moments like a Nike sneaker drop, a Dior perfume launch or new Sony headphones. It waits behind a...